|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
Towards a more balanced world view, Mar 1 2004
Any book that attempts to revise the prevalent Western/White/Post-Industrial/European/American(?) weltanschauung by suggesting HUGE influences from Eastern/Hindu/Islamic/Chinese thought and technology, is bound to get flak.So far, Teresi's book has not got as much flak...which is quite heartwarming. This being the first book of its kind that I have read outside India, I have nothing to compare it with. There are any number of indian publications under the title "Vedic Mathematics", that illustrate the sophistication possible with non-mainstream mathematics. I remember reading a totally original vedic proof of "Pythagoras'" theorem that was elegant, complete and just 3 lines long! However, the author covers so much ground, and attempts to pack tons of information in a moderately sized book (around 300 pages), that at times the facts come faster than the mind can process. And although he's taken the easy way out by classifying chapters with broad categories, that has lead to a lot of repetition of facts within the book. A more efficient categorization would be by actual elements of discussion - say 1) Algebra 2) Civic Amenities 3)Metallurgy . This way a discourse of the general aspects of a civilization could have been relegated to appendices, and the bok itself would have more of a "tabular" comparison approach. But that's just me. Kudos to Teresi for the amount of research done for this book. The references list a staggering number of sources, and so much about my own culture (Indian) was revealed to me through this book. Sadly, the text books in India are lame reincarnations and faded copies of books instituted during the British rule. Consequestly, things like the metallurgical supremacy of South India (Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka ) in ancient times (iron-ore mined in Africa was converted to high grade steel in India and later forged into Damascus blades). The fact that India was a pre-eminent power in cotton textiles and silk that were exported all over the ancient world. The british apparently tried, without success, to duplicate this quality , after they started the industrial revolution. I would totally recommend this book to anyone interested in assigning credit where it is due. And, to those who say "what does it matter?"...it DOES matter to those cultures who have been stripped of pride in their own accomplishments and heritage; Subjugated to sanctions, arm-twisting, and wars that have little justification. Case in point - Baghdad, which was recently bombed, was in fact a medieval center of learning and the modern world owes it a great debt. The region was also host to the ancient Mesopotamian civilizations - Sumerian, Akkadian, etc. I believe that the kind of awareness this book fosters, would reduce some of the short-sightedness that moves people to go out and destroy sites of world heritage.
|