From School Library Journal
Grade 5-8-In 1906, the destruction of the Florida everglades was just beginning, and DeFelice has used this historical setting to give perspective to the troubling ecological situations that are of concern today. Hiding from the New York law for five years in the Florida swamps, Tyler and his parents have survived through strength and love. The respect that they, and the Seminole Indians who live nearby, have for the plants and animals that share their environment contrasts starkly with those who venture into the Everglades for profit. The family is cautious and distrustful of strangers, but when a naturalist who wants to document the flora and fauna appears, they decide to trust him, and the boy is hired out as his guide. The first day out, he is horrified to discover that Mr. Strawbridge plans to kill the birds he finds rather than photograph them, and even more disturbed at his own ability to break a friend's trust and lead the man to a hidden rookery. On the second day, the scientist is coldly murdered by plume hunters, and Tyler must rely on his instincts to survive. The dark and forbidding cover will attract even reluctant readers to this story, but the sense of danger is not sustained, for Tyler is never discovered by the killers, or ever very far from home. The book will appeal more to "green kids" than to those looking for adventure. They'll be pulled in not by tension but by the authentic atmosphere, thick with wild creatures and plants, and the desperate cries of hundreds of orphaned baby birds that will ring in their ears as a reminder of what humans are capable of doing in the name of progress.
Susan Oliver, Tampa-Hillsborough County Public Library SystemCopyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
From Booklist
Gr. 5-7. In 1906, 13-year-old Tyler MacCauley has come to enjoy his simple life in the mosquito-ridden Everglades, especially the beauty and wildness of the egrets, herons, flamingos, ibis, and alligators that make their home there. The family lives close to poverty, having been on the lam ever since his father woke up one day after a drunken stupor next to a corpse in New York City. Rather than face a murder charge, Will McLeod changed his name and fled to a place where no one asks questions. Tyler's Seminole friend teaches him many things about the Everglades and shows him a spectacular rookery, bustling with valuable, multicolored birds. Tyler promises to tell no one. When Hugo M. Strawbridge, an eccentric scientist, later offers Tyler three dollars a day to act as a guide, Tyler feels forced to accept. Little does he anticipate that Strawbridge is just another greedy plume hunter. Strawbridge makes Tyler reveal the secret rookery, pulls out his gun, and starts shooting. The quality of the conflicts in this novel is first-rate--questions of loyalty, honor, trust, value of human life, and environmental concerns focus on the universal struggle between good and evil. What happens to the characters is believable as well as riveting. Once again DeFelice offers an adventure story sure to entertain as well as prod the reader's conscience
Deborah Abbott
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.