Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Striking, May 14 2004
This review is from: Make a Jazz Noise Here (Audio CD)
This album is almost overwhelming at some points. I havn't had it for too long, but Ive listened to it daily and enjoyed every second of it. The musicianship and understanding of the music between the members is amazing. This ranks (for me) above nearly everything (if not everything) that Zappa has put out, for me. This is one of the testemants to his genius. A few of the albums that define his musical ability for composition and musical structure aren't always accessable for the casual fan or people just interested in Zappa's music or more challenging works (such as the yellow shark or Civilization Phaze 3). That is by no means a let down, those albums show, when you really pay attention to everything thats going on, and realize that its not just random notes (aside from the few tracks that alot of close minded people would actually call music), that everything that's being played is meant to be played, are also a testemant to his genius. But sometimes people cant quite wrap their minds around that (which is understandable, although those are 2 of my favorite Zappa works). That's why this album is one of the most amazing outings in Zappa's vast catalog. It's accessible upon first listen, it has alot of humor, alot of Zappa's best songs, including the Black page, the absolutely stunning melody of older tunes on the first disc, a reggea version of King Kong, an incredibly tight rendition of Big Swifty with a couple of really funny "musical quotes" lets call them, kind of like what happens at the end of Stairway to Heaven on The Best Band You've Never Heard in Your Life, Alien Orifice (check out the middle section to that one, HOLY CRAP, what band can do that?!). I wish I had gone into how the songs are, but trust me, it's worth every penny. Unbelievable songs performed by unbelievable musicians created by one of the twentieth century's great composers. My only complaint is that there are some unneccesary (alot of the times sloppy) guitar solo's in the middle of some of the songs, mainly on the second disc. But if you look passed that, which is actually very easy cause they're not all that bad, they just seem unneccesary sometimes, then you have one of the most impressive, enjoyable, stunning outings in Zappa's career. Hands down.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Zappa I love the most, Dec 17 2003
This review is from: Make a Jazz Noise Here (Audio CD)
In my opinion this release from Zappa is a great effort. Actually I don't know his discography so well to say this album is one of the best in his catalogue. But it is surely great above any other consideration. The band is stellar. It seems almost a single instrument in the hand of the director. Here Zappa displays his true genius, his true musical extravaganza. He was a really bad musician but an astounding composer and director. Luckily in this concert he did play very few guitar and directed much more instead. The music here goes from atonal, to free form expression, to Jazz, to grotesque riffs, stolen here and there. It's incredible. The result is a sonic magma of sheere beauty, completly crazy in itself such as was his author. It is surely a difficult and hard listening experience, not for the faint at heart, but it is surely a masterpiece in composing and direction. I prefer the disc 2, it seems to me more complete, more focused .. Anyway. Mesmerizing classical alien music this is what I would call this kind of art. I compare Zappa to Dali', Picasso, Magritte .. maybe Warhol, Haring, Basquiat, Stravinsky, Miles Davis. That kind of people. Kings of imagination.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
An amazingly tight band playing very well, Nov 13 2003
This review is from: Make a Jazz Noise Here (Audio CD)
If you're new to Zappa's catalogue then it can be very daunting to decide what to try out. The man had so many releases and jumped across so many styles that there's no real guarantee that any particular release will do it for you. This album is great for any of you who want to hear Zappa leading a TIGHT, TIGHT band playing mostly instrumental music. There are plenty of "jams" in the jazz sense of the word, not the Grateful Dead sense of the word. In other words, instrumentalists improv within a tight technical structure but the full band never drifts out into unrehearsed meanderings. More than any other release since Waka/Jawaka, this album makes me appreciate Zappa as a composer and bandleader. The man was a force! Having heard well over half of Zappa's output before picking this up, I was a little surprised that it became one of my favorite listens almost immediately. I didn't realize just how good the '88 band was. And, I confess, the relative paucity of stage antics and jokes is actually somewhat refreshing. I just want to hear them play!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|