From Publishers Weekly
Karr (The Great Turkey Walk) captures the hopes and trials of a first-generation Hungarian family struggling to build a farm in southern New Jersey after WWI. She characterizes the five siblings and their parents as a tightly knit group yet clearly differentiates their personalities. The novel's greatest strength is the relationship between the 10-year-old narrator, Istv n, and his soft-spoken, industrious father, Apa. As the eldest son describes the events of a single year, he portrays the importance of his father's role and foreshadows events to come. For example, early in the novel, Apa finds work in Philadelphia, and while he's away the family nearly botches their livelihood. But Karr also communicates the family's strength during Apa's stint away; when the mortgage man arrives with a lascivious proposition to compensate for their missing payments, Anya, Istv n's gentle mother, slaps the man. Hence, the author offers readers some reassurance when the characters later must confront Apa's more sustained absence. Historical details abound (e.g., the second son's passionate interest in automobiles conveys their novelty; Istv n and Apa construct their own radio set), yet the childhood themes will be easily recognizable to readers today. They will root for Istv n as he steps into his father's shoes and remember these winning characters long after the final page has turned. Ages 10-up. (Sept.)
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Grade 4-8-The man of the Csere family is Apa, a lively and enthusiastic fellow who left Hungary to raise his family in America. He is seen through the eyes of his 10-year-old son Istv n, who narrates this warm tale set in South Jersey in the 1920s. The boy loves his father's energetic and optimistic approach to life, and the humor that comes along with it. Apa lets Istv n watch and learn as he schemes to get rid of a weasel, remove stumps with dynamite, and construct a crystal radio set. While his plans aren't always immediately successful, Apa's magnetic and dauntless spirit comes through beautifully. Istv n shows less enthusiasm, however, when his father declares that he must perform on the violin at a Christmas program. Still, Apa's stern insistence, coupled with Istv n's own inner resources, results in a fine performance and a lesson learned. The episodes are amusing and sometimes fascinating, but the warm relationship between father and son lies at the heart of this excellent novel. When Apa dies from an appendicitis attack, Istv n has to take on the role of "man of the family" far sooner than he anticipated. The sad ending is balanced by the boy's realization that he has learned enough from his father to try bravely to follow in his footsteps.
Steven Engelfried, Deschutes County Library, Bend, OR Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.