17 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good overall, wanted an epilogue, Feb 24 2010
By Chase - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Marriage Ring (Mass Market Paperback)
I really wanted to give this book a five star rating, but the end of the book held me back. That's not to say the end of the book was bad (it wasn't) but I was hoping for more. The characters are refreshing and, even though they come to love each other in such a short period of time, the reader can appreciate what they go through together. I wanted this book to keep going and, as I approched the end, I knew it would be wrapped up too quickly. I would have really loved an epilogue...a letter from Grace to her friend Fiona (from Seduction at Christmas) telling of her marriage, or a look ahead to Grace's and Richard's married years...something that would have given me that extra satisfaction at the end of the story.
Other than that, a solid romance and definitely one I will re-read.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Hero steals the scenes in this sweet tale, Mar 17 2010
By Melissa - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Marriage Ring (Mass Market Paperback)
I was delighted with Cathy Maxwell's new tale The Marriage Ring, largely because the hero is so unexpected. He is really the star of this novel.
Richard Lynsted is upright, moral and a wee bit judgmental and even at age twenty-nine he wants his father's approval. He believes he can earn it when he tries to thwart a blackmail attempt against his father and uncle. Problem is the blackmailer is a beautiful Scot who is outspoken and angry.
Grace MacEachin is also trying to win her father's approval. He was convicted of embezzling money from an elderly lady and sent away to a penal colony for years. During her father's absence everything fell apart for Grace, she left her Inverness home for London and is now an actress. She believes in her father's innocence and is convinced that Richard's father and uncle were the real culprits, so she sends them a note demanding money or she will tell the magistrates that they were involved with the embezzlement.
Richard is a fair minded person and after meeting Grace, is willing to hear her side of the story and he is ready to meet her father too. This necessitates a trip to Scotland and it is on this journey that Richard and Grace really discover each other.
Both leads are distrustful and longing for parental approval and yet both have lived their lives very differently. Grace is defiant and her past is less than perfect. Richard is a model citizen but he is missing joy and companionship. During their long journey to Scotland they take stock of their lives and really grow into a loving couple. Grace just seems to mature, she realizes she has been headstrong and her escape to London was not ever going to solve her problems.
Richard is so good and honorable it is almost impossible not to like him. Yes, he is a bit reserved but he is also incredibly kind hearted, brave and heartbreakingly vulnerable too. His metamorphosis from stern unbending barrister to open hearted, loving hero is wonderful.
There are a few sections of this novel that get bogged down a little and Grace is a little too forward but hero Richard more than makes up for these little problems. The dialogue is also good (these two speak to each other with respect and affection). This is a definite recommend.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
"hard to get through", April 13 2010
By pen pen - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Marriage Ring (Mass Market Paperback)
This was just not my cup of tea. For one the hero is a virgin. The plot was pretty good but, it was just too much going on. I really was disapointed considering how much I liked her last book. Not hot enough!