Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
I LOVE this graphic novelJan. 21 2010
- Published on Amazon.com
I bought the Marvel graphic novel of The Picture of Dorian Gray. I had to buy it on amazon because the nearest Barns and Nobel has a very small and somewhat lacking graphic novel section. The Marvel graphic noel is very nice.
I also bought a graphic novel version from Sterling press. I wasn't sure which one I'd prefer.
Well, after looking at them there's no contest. The Marvel one is definitely a far superior version. The illustrations are gorgeous. It's a word for word adaptation of the novel. Everyone looks the way I imagine them from the original book, save for Basil. I think the graphic novel version of Basil is far more attractive than my mind gave him credit for. Strangely, I'd say he even looks a bit like Ben Barnes' version of Dorian. Lord Henry always looks the same in almost every adaptation so his appearance was no surprise to me.
I'm very disappointed in the Sterling edition though. The Sterling Picture of Dorian Gray graphic novel is done in this art deco 1920s type of style where everything's flat, straight lined, sharp edged, and Dorian is drawn vaguely like the nineteen thirties film version, and not at all like the literary version. It's also a far rougher adaptation. Lots of heavy edits and lacking in scene detail in the art work.
Out of the two graphic novel versions of The Picture of Dorian Gray I strongly prefer the Marvel version. I highly recommend it to any Oscar Wilde fan. The Sterling version... not so much.
The story itself is fantastic.
I LOVE the work of Oscar Wilde. Allow me to stress that. I absolutely love the work of Oscar Wilde. My two favourite works of his are The Canterville Ghost and The Picture of Dorian Gray.
The Picture of Dorian Gray tells the story of a young man who sells his soul for eternal youth and beauty. While he remains flawless, a portrait of himself grows uglier every time he sins. He cannot die unless you destroy the painting. Thanks to temptation and vice Dorian falls into hedonism and debauchery. As he externally remains pure and untainted his soul bears the burdens of his actions as reflected in the painting. Dorian learns the hard way that it's not physical beauty that matters but the inner beauty of one's own soul in qualities of kindness, mercy and compassion, things that he had lost along the way for selfishness, hedonism and greed.
Dorian's fall from grace is a road lined with wit and humour. The story is riddled with clever epigrams (witty, short sayings) mostly said by the morally questionable character, Lord Henry. Lord Henry is a surprisingly naive character who plants bad ideas and temptations into Dorian's head while he, himself, doesn't seem to actually commit any sin he talks about. He even has the naive notion that people of their status don't do things like murder, as if such crimes are vices only of the lower classes.
The picture of Dorian Gray is a very good and interesting read that talks about social conformity, morality, hedonism, and good and evil. The messages are not heavy handed and it's an intelligently written story.
People of Oscar Wilde's era who called it an immoral book were made uncomfortable by Dorian's descent and lack of redemption but ultimately he was punished for his sins. Others noticed the subtle hints of homosexuality and bisexuality in the story but these things were kept subtle as this was a Gothic Victorian novel. Many people over-estimate how much homosexual content there is in this book or they don't see it at all but in fact it was actually very subtle and you only notice it if you are looking for it. However lines such as 'The world is changed because you are made of ivory and gold. The curve of your lips rewrite history.' - which was engraved in a cigarette case given to Dorian by Lord Henry make the relationships obvious to the astute reader.
The sexuality of the characters isn't even an issue. Poor Oscar Wilde was far ahead of his time in this regard.
It's Dorian's decadence, hedonism and selfishness that cause his downfall and prove the moral lesson of the story; the value of the soul and inner beauty over external eternal flawlessness. Dorian might have had eternal youth and beauty but it was at the price of the eternal beauty and youth that comes from a good natured and kind soul. And Dorian, being an aesthete could only see this transformation when his soul was physically manifested in a portrait that changed with the changing of his nature. The 1940s movie adaptation of the story (the first film adaptation of The Picture of Dorian Gray) held the hope of redemption in showing that in acts of compassion the portrait could change for the better. This was something the novel lacked though it is still a fine novel. Oscar Wilde was right when he said there is no such thing as a moral or immoral book. There's only well written or poorly written books and The Picture of Dorian Gray is very well written.
This isn't an action packed thriller (though there are some intense moments). This isn't a romance about an immortal with a teenage lover (though something of that does happen). This is NOT Twilight. This story actually has substance. This is more of an exploration of a character's nature and all of human nature in the process, the flaws of modern superficiality, selfishness and hedonism and the power the spiritual can still have over human consciousness. It's sad that for all of Dorian's shallowness he had to physically see it to feel the weight of his conscience instead of just knowing what he was doing was wrong but this is the flaw of the character and the reason behind his downfall. Dorian was a true aesthete to a dangerous extreme. Oscar Wilde was making a statement about society that many even today either don't get or don't want to get.
The Picture of Dorian Gray is written in a nice flowing prose. It's written in a third person perspective novel, not first person perspective, not alternating, and certainly not epistolary (which was a very popular style of fiction writing in Oscar Wilde's time).
I strongly recommend The Picture of Dorian Gray. It is a true classic.
The best graphic novel version though is Marvel's version where I really don't care for how they edited and drew the Sterling graphic novel version of The Picture of Dorian Gray graphic novel.
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful
Fantastic for Reading and TeachingDec 10 2008
The Spotless Mind
- Published on Amazon.com
I'm an English/ESL teacher and just dropped my old copies of Dorian Gray in order to use this text to teach my class. The students in my class range from 13-19 years old, and from beginners to fairly fluent English speakers. This text has actually allowed me to use the same text with all my students. It has very challenging vocabulary I am using with my higher level students, and includes the interesting historical details that are left out of the Penguin Reader version. I'm finding that my intermediate students love it for the wonderful illustrations and that they are rising to the challenge of the language. The pictures are compelling materials for my beginners to use to label and write captions, and in this way they are able to access vocabulary and important elements of the story. What a great book!
A Bargain with the Devil...April 19 2010
- Published on Amazon.com
"The Picture of Dorian Gray" may be Oscar Wilde's best known literary legacy, the horrifying story of a handsome youth who makes a terrible bargain to remain forever young. Author Roy Thomas and illustrator Sebastian Fiumara have worked wonders in translating a novel filled with philosophical rhetoric into a dramatic graphic novel for Marvel Illustrated.
As the story opens, the artist Basil Hayward is completing the portrait of a handsome young man. Hayward introduces his friend Lord Henry Wotton to the subject of the painting, one Dorian Gray. Lord Henry has an instant corrupting influence on Dorian, who, overwhelmed both with the beauty of his portrait and a sudden fear of growing old, offers his soul to avoid change.
Lord Henry will continue his corrupting influence on Dorian, who quickly discovers the possibilities of a dissolute life spend corrupting others. This corruption will lead to a terrible murder, a coverup, and finally a reckoning neither Dorian Gray nor likely the reader could have anticipated.
Roy Thomas has captured the essence of the suspense and building horror of the original novel, greatly aided by Fiumara's dramatic artwork. The story, filled with mature themes, is intended for young adults. To that audience, it is very highly recommended as an introduction to Oscar Wilde and his work.
So Beautiful!Aug. 11 2011
- Published on Amazon.com
This is Oscar Wilde's classic tale of the moral fall of an innocent. A dark story, do not expect Picture of Doraian Gray to be a light comedy, a grand love story or a heartwarming everyone's-happy-in-the-end tale.
Since the key item in the story is a captivating painting of Dorian Gray, it was essential that Marvel lined up just the right artist. That they did. The artwork is realistic, not cartoony, and has a painted feel. The colors are rich yet muted. The text mirrors the original classic. Wilde's witty observations on life and the aristocracy translate well.
This book is an excellent companion piece to Wilde's novella. I even lent a copy to a friend who loves the classics but does not read comics. She enjoyed it as well! It would be great as an introduction to classic literature, in or out of the classroom. The book includes a glossary to help younger or less well read readers, thus providing help while not "dumbing down" the text.
If you like this item, you will probably also enjoy the highly humorous and entertaining film, The Importance of Being Earnest.
Very niceApril 4 2010
- Published on Amazon.com
I liked this book a lot. It has WONDERFUL illustrations and keeps true to the story. Very nice.