Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
Avengers Vol 9 - offers some good character driven storiesJune 29 2014
- Published on Amazon.com
This volume of the Marvel Masterworks series continues the run of Earth's Mightiest Heroes during the era that I remember most - a time when Marvel Comics was turning out some of its most memorable story lines from the talents of writer Roy Thomas and artist John Buscema - it is these stories and images that I will always associate with the Avengers.
Now, as they were back then, John Buscema's panels are irresistable, as he can make even the most casual and subtle scenes eye-catching - and his action scenes are as enthralling today as they were to an impressionable ten year old back in the 70's. Roy Thomas' stories seem to have no limit to where they will take the heroes - some really far-fetched and bordering on the ridiculous but inevitably they always end up with a clever twist that make it all worth while. Of the many titles he wrote for Marvel, he had a definite gift for the Avengers. *It is noted that the latter chapters are written by Harlan Ellison and drawn by Sal Buscema, Herb Trimpe and Frank Giacoia.
In Vol 9 - we have series that center on a roster that seem to be hitting their stride - I will elude to the great Kree/Skrull War that shortly followed this series, as a landmark point, which this reader considers the team's greatest adventure - though this book compares little to that stellar epic, it succeeds in continuing to delve into the personalities of the heroes, which would give the characters good depth. An example is - we get a look into the goings-on inside Avengers Mansion - at what happens when the heroes have that rare downtime - in one chapter, we see the origins of the Black Panther - and we get a sort of sitting around the campfire feel, as the other members prompt T'Challa to tell his story.
Of course this series may best be noted for its centerpiece story the introduction of Red Wolf - a Native American hero, who has an interesting story himself, which involves a crooked businessman named Van Lunt and the crime group called Zodiac - this starts the book off on a good note - or even perhaps the book is known for the unconventional tale of the Lady Liberators - in which the female Avengers get involved in a sort of renegade mission that is underscored by a social issue that was headlines at the time - Battle of the Sexes - this story stands out for its message but is rather light on the excitement.
Another story involves the Squadron Supreme (Squadron Sinister) in other stories - which in this reader's opinion was getting way too much attention among the panels during this and preceding volumes - this team of heroes or villains in some cases, continues to fail to impress me, they offer nothing but very cliche personalities and I just kept hoping they would get the boot - this is the primary flaw in this book. With that said I did however enjoy seeing the villain Arkon the Magnificent return - as he was, in my opinion, a much more interesting and charismatic character.
The last chapter involves the Hulk and a villain called Psyklop - this story is quite different than what you might expect from the pages of the Hulk in that it touches on a delicate theme where Hulk is actually welcomed and loved by a race of aliens with grin skin led by its lovely monarch Jarella - this chapter is actually quite good but too brief - I would have rather seen this book devote more pages to this story than the ridiculous Squadron "chumps"
Overall its a good entry in the Thomas/Buscema run and is recommended for collectors of classic Avengers.
An Uneven Mess, but Still Fun in the Silver Age FashionMarch 17 2015
R. H. Rich
- Published on Amazon.com
Contains issues # 80-88 and Incredible Hulk # 140. A really strange mix in this volume. We start with the two-part introduction of Red Wolf, a 1970s-era Native American hero and ham-handed attempt at social consciousness from Rascally Roy Thomas. Red Wolf is swapped out for the more interesting Daredevil for part 3 of the Zodiac saga in # 82. # 83 "introduces" Valkyrie, sort-of. I'll avoid spoilers, but it sets up the return of Arkon in # 84. # 85-86 is a parallel universe story with the Squadron Supreme. Roy seems obsessed with these JLA/JSA tributes, but this one has an interesting twist at the end. # 87 is a stand-alone expansion of Black Panther's origin. Strange to see that in Avengers, but it's suitably pulpy. # 88 and Hulk # 140 are a loose two-parter "plotted" by Harlan Ellison, but they never really seem to come together into something coherent. The villain, Psyklop, is beyond shallow. It's like Harlan wrote a parody of superhero comics. An uneven mess, but still fun in the Silver Age fashion.
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
A GREAT RETURN TO A GOLDEN AGE!!Nov. 17 2013
- Published on Amazon.com
At one time I had a complete run of the Avengers. It was nice to find this volume as Red Wolf was always one of my favorite characters. It was very nice to have these issues once again, especially in a hardback.