3.0 out of 5 stars
A VERY mixed bag., Mar 21 2001
This review is from: Merro Tree (Mass Market Paperback)
"The Merro Tree" can be best described as "The Lion King" meets "A Bug's Life" on the set of "Star Wars". And, indeed, this milder, more verbose variation on "Ender's Game" would feel right at home in a galaxy far, far away. There is absolutely no science involved here. The dull, unimaginative aliens include dog-men, snake-men, bee-men, emotionless, mechanical men, and blue-skinned men. Apparently, all planets in the galaxy share a Mediterranian climate and atmosphere, and any alien can survive on a diet of foreign food.
Yes, this book deals with personal freedoms, censorship, and same-sex love, but it deals with those subjects in a shallow, inadequate way. The good is a bit too good, and the evil, instead of being ambiguous, is definitely, outrageously evil. Even the book's centerpiece same-sex (but different species) romance is contrived and artificial. Ms. Waitman seems convinced that the success of such relationships lies in two things: constant mutual gratification and a knack for femininity.
"The Merro Tree" is about the blossoming talent of a young prodigy, told in parallel with our now-aged hero's struggle against a galactic ban on his unique art. An entertaining concept, certainly. But the characters are almost entirely two-dimensional and the prose tends to be flowery and melodramatic. Mikk is not entertaining in his role as the main character. As the book starts out, his personality seems shifting and impermanent. For a good deal of time, his young aspect is shy and clumsy, but that goes away within several pages with little or no explanation. Which is really a pity, since two-thirds of the way in, Ms. Waitman wakes up and takes advantage of the reader's pent-up jealousy for Mikk's apparently inborn talents. Soon, she starts pulling on other strings, and the book gains a surprisingly effective amount of drama and pathos, but nevertheless manages to end on a flat and mystifying note.
Ms. Waitman has definite talent. Unfortunately, her characters in "The Merro Tree" take a great deal of time to take shape, and most of the dialog is either stunted or predictable. In her next work, "The Divided", Ms. Waitman fixes some of her errors, but some are still there. Watch for her upcoming works.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Read this Book!!, Feb 27 2001
This review is from: Merro Tree (Mass Market Paperback)
I love this book!
Katie Waitman shows true talent with a wide variety of interesting characters, an enthralling plot and a beautiful love story!
This book was so good that the first time I read it I turned it over and began reading it again just so I could become part of Katie's well thought out and vivid world again!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No