| |||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to the Hardcover edition.There is WAAY too much yadda yadda kind of macro-analysis that doesn't address specifics of the music, including a long exposition into the writing and theories of Ken Wilber. I say cut the **** and cut to the chase.
He overuses Miles' autobiography with Quincy Troupe as a source. I consider that document to be self-serving in the extreme and frequently fictional, and I wouldn't use it as a source without corroboration. He also frequently denigrates Chambers' Milestones, which I consider the best overall book to date regarding Miles' life and career. This is probably no more than professional rivalry, but it lessens this book.
The analysis of the various recording dates and output mostly jibes with my takes on the same recordings, but is incomplete. Nothing in his analysis is striking or displays insight that a half-sophisticated listener couldn't arrive at. Lester Bangs did several early 70s contemporaneous reviews of this material that showed much more depth of thought. And he ignores quite a few live dates that should have been available to him as a researcher.
All in all, I wouldn't give this more than three or three and a half of five stars. It's a nice start, but certainly not the definitive book about this period. I see John Szwed has a new MIles bio out - he did a great job with his Sun Ra bio, so maybe his will be the new definitive work.
The other reviews I've read above describe perfectly what I got out of this book. Read more