From Amazon
This is one YA novel that can be read and enjoyed by readers of any age. With characters that leap off the page and humour that borders on the hysterical, Susan Juby crosses the line between adult and young adult, even as her main character, Alice MacLeod, 16, is making her own valiant attempt to leave childhood behind. It is anything but a smooth transition.
Miss Smithers, like its popular predecessor,
Alice, I Think, consists entirely of Alice's diary entries and her short journal pieces (she's a budding reporter). The storyline is straightforward: Alice, the daughter of vegetarian parents and sister of nerdy 11-year-old MacGregor, is enticed to enter the Miss Smithers Pageant in her home town of Smithers, B.C., by the $400 clothing allowance, which she immediately blows on a pair of leather pants. Alice is to represent the local Rod & Gun Club against 13 other participants including Miss Evelyn Station Fish Hatchery and Miss Chicken Creek Fire Department. Juby perfectly captures the wry and desperate humour of a teenager, as when Alice's mother "made the birthday cake with sugar rather than the usual cane-juice, in flagrant defiance of hippie vegetarian dietary laws. Will the good times never end?" Meanwhile, Alice has broken up with her bumbling boyfriend, Goose, and her best friend has lost her virginity. While this delightful novel has many good moments, the highlight is a fashion show in which one shy contestant models a skimpy bikini crocheted by the Ladies' Auxiliary Society. Altogether, this is a believable story with characters that feel fully alive.
--Mark Frutkin
--This text refers to an alternate
Paperback
edition.
From School Library Journal
Grade 9 Up–Alice MacLeod, 16, had been homeschooled since being pulled out of first grade for thinking she was a hobbit. Now she attends alternative school, and describes herself as "a total misfit," so she is understandably surprised when the Smithers Rod and Gun Club asks her to be their representative for the local beauty pageant. She keeps a diary of all of her school and pageant misadventures, including cantankerous descriptions of her hippie parents, friends, and fellow contestants. Alice's meanderings through a religious group, alcohol experimentation, and fruitless hopes for a first sexual encounter seem contrived for their shock value. Although she is certainly intelligent and insightful (with a very sharp cutting edge), she never seems to understand that she's her own worst enemy until the end. By that point, it's too little too late, and readers will have trouble caring if she gets it or not. She seems to veer from one ridiculous or dangerous situation to the next, and blames much of it on everybody else (sometimes correctly, but often not). Despite its wit and spearing of inane beauty contests, teens will have trouble finding this book's heart, or Alice's.
–Paula J. LaRue, Van Wert City Schools, OH Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.