From School Library Journal
Grade 1-3–Ameer is a poor, third-assistant kennel keeper traveling in his king's caravan to visit the Christ child. Arriving in Bethlehem, he feels ashamed of having no gift to give and decides to wait outside the stable instead of going in to view the newborn. In the chaos of the moment, however, he is swept along by the crowd and into the presence of the holy family. Inspired by the serenity he feels, he resolves to give the only thing that is precious to him–his dog and best friend, Ra. The king advises against it, but Mary praises Ameer for his sacrifice, calling it the most precious gift of all. As a result, the boy's life is blessed, Ra sees Jesus and his family safely to Egypt, and, over time, the Christmas star fades and is replaced by the Dog Star. This touching story is simply yet elegantly told. Cooper's artwork is finely rendered and evocative. The grainy textures complement the desert scenery and provide a fitting dreamlike quality that is well suited to the text. This lovely book will help balance collections heavy with holiday frippery.
–Linda Israelson, Los Angeles Public Library Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
The story is a familiar one. A young boy is on his way to see the baby Jesus but has no gift to bring. Here the boy is Ameer, the third assistant kennel keeper, who is following the caravan of his merchant master with his dog, Ra, whom he rescued as a pup. What exactly Ameer is doing on this particular journey is never really made clear, but both Crisp's heartfelt story and Cooper's soft-edged artwork capture his yearning to honor the baby in appropriate fashion. In the end, Ameer decides to give up his beloved dog to the child, and listeners may be surprised that Mary and Joseph accept the gift, which is so dear to Ameer. Cooper's art utilizes night colors highlighted by golds and browns to tell the story, in which all the major characters appear to be of African descent. An intriguing author's note describes the fact that a white dog is repeatedly portrayed in fourteenth- through sixteenth-century Nativity paintings, which were the impetus for Crisp's story.
Ilene CooperCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved