3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Miserable and Disturbing Stories, Feb 26 2009
By *~ Sunshine ~* - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: My Mother Never Dies (Hardcover)
Pre-release customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program
I must admit that I have to struggle to find anything positive to write about "My Mother Never Dies", but that may just be me. Throughout the book, I maintained hope that there would be something redeeming. It never happened. These snippets of the worst examples of mother/daughter relationships and humanity in general just kept coming, each either equally bad or worse than the last. I have to wonder why someone would choose this subject matter. Oh yes, shock value, and it does have plenty of that. I usually read for pleasure though, and entertainment, and I would not use either of these words to describe this book.
The author, Claire Castillon, does have her own, not totally unappealing style, though I found the sentences broken and difficult to follow at times, possibly due to translation to English. I would consider reading her work again if on other, more pleasant, subject matter.
If you are seeking an off-beat, shocking, book of short, easy-to-read stories, you may consider giving this a try. But be forewarned, it is not a "feel good" accounting of mother and daughter relationships. I came away with a sense of great gratitude that neither my mother, nor any women that I have known, vaguely resembled any of those in this book. Maybe that was her goal.
Edit: In fairness, the one star would be for this books subject matter. As a writer, I would give her three.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Bad mothers, Feb 13 2009
By Orion - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: My Mother Never Dies (Hardcover)
Pre-release customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program
Here we have every kind of bad mother cliche you can think of. There is the pill-popping mother, the mother who overlooks incest, the mother obsessed with appearances, the mother who refuses to act like an adult. There are a few messed up daughters as well. A lot of these stories are extreme cases of the conflicts every family experiences from time to time. Others are just strange.
I suppose there are people who will find all this melodrama fascinating. I wasn't really very interested in it.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Antidote to the Smiling Mommy Stories, Mar 26 2009
By Rachel Kramer Bussel "Cupcakes Take the Cake ... - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: My Mother Never Dies (Hardcover)
Pre-release customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program
These short, sharp stories are almost a sucker punch to the images of the glowing mom, or the yummy mummy, or the perfectly happy mother-daughter pairs, the ones who refer to themselves as best friends. Castillon captures women's ambivalence about parenthood, even hatred of it, as well as the complexity of being a daughter with tight prose that makes you both long for more to each story, and thrilled at the exquisiteness packed into each one. Chilling and snappy, and nothing like what you'll see in the tabloids.