5.0 out of 5 stars
Best mystery writer I've read in a long time, Jun 13 2004
This review is from: Murder on the Leviathan: A Novel (Hardcover)
What a great book! It had everything - humor, cultural differences and misunderstandings, history and murder. Most importantly, I was surprised by the ending - did not expect it.
I liked how he told the story from the viewpoint of the suspects. I don't think we ever really got to read about the detective's opinion, which gave him a sense of mystery (I have not read The Winter Queen, yet). It also highlighted the opinions of the Europeans toward the Japanese passenger - I believe their opinions were pretty realistic with what Europeans and Americans thought of Asians at that time. It was a good look at how people's prejudices can get in the way of the truth. The author got in a few humorous digs at British and French imperialism.
I highly recommend this book. I am surprised how few people have reviewed this book. I think it is better written, more clever and more interesting than other more popular mystery writers. I can't wait for his other books to come out here in the US. Yes, he does remind me of Agatha Christie.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Christie Homage Done Well, May 25 2004
This review is from: Murder on the Leviathan: A Novel (Hardcover)
It is impossible to read Boris Akunin's Murder on the Leviathan (ably translated by Andrew Bromfield) without automatically thinking of Agatha Christie. All of her various character types are here, with a clever riff/spoof of both Hercule Poirot and the French detectives he would on occasion encounter. It is a compact book with a great number of red herrings thrown about, the perfect summer read for those who have already worked their way through the Christe oeuvre a couple times over and have tired of more contemporary psychological thrillers. This mystery may be way over the top at times but, like a good Agatha Christie, it is always a pleasure.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
funny, eccentric, ingenious!, May 9 2004
This review is from: Murder on the Leviathan: A Novel (Hardcover)
I'm afraid I might have done Boris Akunin a great disservice. I thought The Winter Queen was a decidedly average read; I didn't find the plot too gripping, and I disliked the style. Now, there's nothing I can do about the plot: I've simply never been fond of "adventure" stories, so I'm not particularly going to like a pastiche of one, either - as The Winter Queen was. However, I must have been in some bizarre mood, because I found the style of Leviathan to be an absolute delight!
This is the third Erast Fandorin novel - the second to be translated into English (Turkish Gambit, the real 2nd, is scheduled for publication in December). Here, we see less of Fandorin than we did in TWQ, or it certainly seems like it. This is partly because Leviathan is told from five different perspectives. One is that of French "Investigator of Especially Important Cases", Gustav Gauche (who definitely lives up to his name); the remaining four perspectives are those of four main suspects in a murder inquiry (two of these are told in the 3rd person, two in the 1st). Thus we see Fandorin through only their eyes, making him a decidedly enigmatic and intriguing detective.
The crime being investigated is the murder, in Paris, of Lord Littleby, collector of fine things, and nine members of his staff. (Yes, nine.) Due to a clue left at the crime scene (in the form of a badge shaped as a golden whale), Gauche deduces that the murderer will be one of the passengers on the steamship Leviathan - newly built and embarking upon its maiden voyage to Calcutta. He boards the ship and begins his enquiries, trying to sift out the murder from the 142 first-class passengers (yes, 142.)
As evidenced partly by the ridiculous number of suspects and murder victims (in the end it totals 11), Akunin is clearly having a good time pointing fun at the traditions of the detective genre. And he does it very well indeed. Leviathan is an excellent detective story in its own right, while all the while it gently makes fun of itself and the genre - as TWQ did with espionage fiction. It is a hilarious novel at times; a brilliant, incredibly clever pastiche.
Akunin's main source here is, of course, Agatha Christie. The set-up is immediately recognisable as almost classic Christie, a la Murder on the Orient Express or Death on the Nile. He even manages to work in Cards on the Table and The Clocks (particularly hilariously!) among others, and that is on top off the usual Russian literary influences. For example, one of the periphery characters mentioned is named "Marcel Prout".
Leviathan is an absolutely excellent novel. I would recommend it to anyone. It is not necessary to have read The Winter Queen, and I'd probably advise that you just jump straight in here. Akunin's 2nd novel in translation is an incredibly sharp, teasing, funny, and ingenious mystery, with a great set of characters. A Japanese passenger, one of the four main suspects, is particularly wonderful. Certainly, it was his sections of the book I enjoyed most of all, highlighting fascinatingly the class of 19th century cultures. Plus, his sections of narrative are the only time I have ever come across a book that is part-written in what I can only describe as "landscape".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No