3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Where did akhenatens treasure GO??? By Queen Kiya wife no 2, Dec 20 2003
This review is from: Mystery Of The Copper Scroll Of Qumran (Paperback)
I loved reading this book the author has done a lot of reserch about the subject, it was always intriguing it was like being on a mystical treasure hunt. If you like reading about akhehnaten this is something different from the usual akhenaten books. Well done Robert Feather.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Author's Response, May 9 2004
This review is from: Mystery Of The Copper Scroll Of Qumran (Paperback)
One of the reviews of my book, by an anonymous reader, states I have some responsibility for recent damage at Amarna by treasure hunters, because I suggest possible locations of treasure in my book.
Firstly the recent damage was to boundary stelae, which I never suggested were treasure locations. Not even an idiot blows up a place where he or she is looking for valuables. This was clearly an act of vandalism in a region where political dissension and resentment has an ongoing history. Robbery at Amarna, and for that matter tombs and historical sites across Egypt has been going on for thousands of years, and is still going on. Am I responsible for these too? I deplore these acts. Patently it is nonsense and small minded to suggest anyone should stop indicating the possible location of artefacts. There are dozens of books and articles on the treasures of the Copper Scroll, citing possible places of treasures. Are they all to be withdrawn from publication - not to mention every other work that postulates potential new places where something important lies hidden.
The nameless reader claims the book contains fabrications. I challenge him, or her, to say what has been fabricated. A number of eminent scholars, including Professor Harold Ellens, of Michigan University, Drs Minna and Kenneth Lonnqvist, University of Helsinki, and many more, have come out and backed my central theory and the evidence is pilling up that there was indeed a connection from Amarna to the Second Temple Israelite period, and specifically to the Qumran-Essenes.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1.0 out of 5 stars
A recipe for vandalism, May 7 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Mystery Of The Copper Scroll Of Qumran (Paperback)
This is probably the only book I have ever read which was not only absolute fabrication but also responsible for the destruction of ancient monuments. The author has taken a bunch of half-digested theory about mythical items and fabricated a theory. While this might otherwise be only amusing, recent reports from archaeologists at the site of Akhenaten's capital city point out that a couple of the ancient boundary stela have been blown up by treasure hunters. (The book was abstracted in Arabic and published in one of Egypt's major newspapers). Although the author cannot be held directly responsible for this, his far-fetched theories are the direct inspiration for these vandals' acts.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No