5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Sloan album that sounds like Sloan, Nov 15 2006
This review is from: Never Hear The End Of It (Audio CD)
Whenever Sloan releases a new album the fans and critics alike look to whom they can compare the sounds and styles. Throughout dozens of reviews you can hear the Beatles, AC/DC, the Smiths, Paul McCartney - even Chicago! - and many others mentioned. This is the first Sloan album that I actually made me think of previous Sloan albums. This is remarkable because it is a fresh album with many fresh ideas, something that Sloan can always be counted on. And yet the revival of the old piano and inclusion of more acoustic guitar rock reminds me of the phenomenal album Navy Blues; the drum sound is like that on Pretty Together and Action Pact; some of the feedback and distortion sounds are reminiscent of Smeared; and Chris's Ana Lucia sounds musically very much like Andrew's Never Seeing the Ground for the Sky on Pretty Together. So, Sloan sounds like Sloan! In a way, it's like they have "run the gamut" as Chris said and included a little bit of everything from their colourful career as well as worked out some new ideas.
For variety, have a listen to Patrick's simple yet beautiful melancholy melodies in Listen to the Radio, Jay's piano rocker Who Taught You to Live Like That, Chris's piano ballad Live the Life You're Dreaming Of, Andrew's guitar rocker Living with The Masses, and Patrick's hardcore punk NFXNSCH. And there's plenty more in between. Chris's People Think They Know Me is a pleasant surprise as it is heavy and somewhat angry with some cool guitar playing.
Like most Sloan songs, the tracks generally clock in at under three minutes with a few going a bit longer. There are also some short "bridges" of songs that are only around one minute and connect the longer ones. All four members are here and contributing and singing adding to the variety. After the first couple of spins I found myself wanting to hear at least half the songs again and again, and after a few more listens I wanted to simply enjoy the whole album as a master piece in itself.
The only regrettable point is that this album will probably not go down in history as a monster album. If Sloan were a British or American band and this album was released in 1992 then by now it would be a cult classic and listed as one of the top twenty albums to own of the 90s. Unfortunately, this album will only be appreciated by fans new and old. For an album that is out of its time, an album that only a band like Sloan could do, this is a prize piece of work. I am glad we have Sloan!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Instant Classic, Oct 1 2006
This review is from: Never Hear The End Of It (Audio CD)
Destined to be in alot of critic's Top Ten Lists of the year's best music, this album is tuneful, it rocks, it has the kind of harmonies most bands can only dream about and is a goldmine of large and (sometimes very) small musical treasures. It's a rare treat these days to have an album leaving you wanting more. Several of the songs' melodies and choruses are permanently locked into my mind at this point. Many small moments of genius abound throughout its entire 30-song package and the comparisons to The White Album and Abbey Road are not as ridiculous as they might sound. Unfortunately for Sloan they will likely not get much play in the US, which means they won't get the popularity and respect they deserve... a shame for all those who will miss this great classic. Sloan is truly one of the best kept secrets of the last 15 years. Buy it - you won't be disappointed; and by all means, go see them live - they are one of the best live acts around.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Sloan- A Very Good Album, Mar 28 2009
This review is from: Never Hear The End Of It (Audio CD)
This is a great album! Creative mixed melodies and a great artistic compilation. One of the few albums I felt I HAD to review.
Some songs are -not that great though-so it Just doesn't equal a full five stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No