From School Library Journal
Grade 5-8–For all those horse-crazy readers, this is a satisfying exploration of how the realities of owning an animal and the responsibility for its care and training affect a family that is already struggling to make ends meet. Nathaniel, 12, explains how he and his sisters, Cid, 14, and Queenie, 8, acquire a pony as a giveaway. Their mother is so laden with her own pain (the children's father has deserted the family) and her efforts to eke out a living that the kids leave her out of the loop on many of their decisions. The inevitable major battles as well as true caring among the siblings are equally present, as are peripheral adults both kind and mean who influence the plot. This is one of the best horse stories to come along in recent years, and one of the few with a male protagonist. In the end, the author makes it clear that losses and gains go together in life, but that one's own actions and choices matter most of all.
–Carol A. Edwards, Douglas County Libraries, Castle Rock, CO Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Gr. 5-8. It is no small thing to care for those we love, as 12-year-old Nathaniel comes to understand in this innocent story, set in Canada in 1977. Nathaniel is one of three siblings who become the owners of a beautiful stallion named Smokey. Smokey is the bright spot in their lives, an antidote to having their world disrupted when their father walked out on them four years earlier. While their mother struggles to pay for food and rent, Nathaniel's paper route provides money for the pony's upkeep. Eight-year-old Queenie, who finds safety in "a secret place in her head," and tough, 10-year-old Cid help with Smokey's care. Then the children's hard-won happiness is threatened again--by a riding accident, a broken heart, and a barn fire. Nathaniel's voice sounds too mature and a touch didactic at times, but the pacing and characterizations are deftly accomplished. And readers will find much to like in the involving, gentle tale.
Cindy WelchCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved