4.0 out of 5 stars
A great story, sad, moving and motivating, Aug 27 2000
....A very little known fact of World War II, was the work of the
Jewish Resistance. Millions of European Jews perished in the
holocaust, specifically being hunted, for no reason but their origin.
Many run away, a few managed to hide and there also were the Jewish
Partisans; those who fought back.
If not now .. when?, is an
absolutely beautiful story of those brave souls who fought the
oppression. This is not a graphic book of the suffering of the
holocaust; this is a great novel about a group of people who despite
of all the suffering keep moving forward. They do hold it together,
they make friends, love, sing, and cry, celebrate and mourn. This is
not a war story, it is a people story, and how they changed and
adapted, how they kept going. Yes, the overused expression of
"triumph of the human spirit" so appropriately describes the
theme of the book, but not always; Levi is realistic enough to see to
that.
I was profoundly touched by this book and thoroughly enjoyed
it as a non-Jew. I never saw this book as a journey to
Palestine....These were people rising up to fight injustice and to
stay alive, they largely moved aimlessly. To interpret this book as a
part of the zinonist movement would in my opinion be wrong.
This is
translated book, it is excellent in English, and it must have been
even better in Italian. I wish I could read it in its original
language.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Classic Levi, July 20 2000
I went through a period when I was choosing (who knows why) only thin books to read. In my search I found To The Lighthouse and One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich. I also found Periodic Table by Levi. The book was shatteringly good. Who was this man? Why hadn't I heard his name mentioned before in the pantheon of Holocaust authors and literature?
If Not Now, When? is classic Levi. In his immutable style he weaves the tale of Jewish partisans making their way across Eastern Europe into Italy in the final 18 months of WWII. Levi doesn't stretch, he doesn't aggrandize, he doesn't use hyperbole. His telling is straight and clean and true. Many authors have grandly failed to described the chaos in the final months of the war. In his direct style, Levi accomphishes it amazingly.
It seems authors and their works always find their place in the world. But Levi didn't in his lifetime and he hasn't yet in ours. He deserves to be read and acknowledged as one of the best.
(Please Note: I, in principal, believe that the rating of reviewers seriously affects the alturism of the review process. Therefore I request that you do NOT indicate if this review has helped you or not)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
If am not for myself, who will be for me?, Jun 18 2000
"If am not for myself, who will be for me? If am for myself alone, what am I? If not now, when." This is a famous passage of Rabbi Hillel, and they are the appropriate words to use as title for this book. It is a fictional narrative of a group of Jewish partisans, following their track from Russia to Italy, along 1943/45. Without sensationalism, avoiding detailed descriptions of horror, and using a touch of humor, Primo Levi describes the hardships of partisans who rebelled against injustice armed themselves and carried their own personal war against the enemy, united by a commmon goal to reach Palestine. Interesting characters are developed, and a narrative always with tension and emotion. A Tale of heroism based on documented records of WWII. Primo Levi is not evasive when it comes to his honest thoughts about the enemies (whether Germans, Russians, or Polish) but his message is one of universal human solidarity. Beautifully written, with a fantastic human touch.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No