1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I thought we'd change things, but we didn't change a thing., July 3 2009
By Jason Stein - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Notes & Rhymes (Audio CD)
I hand it to Craig and Charlie Reid for persevering over the past 22 years since the release of their debut. I mean they aren't well known in the U.S. other than their one top 40 hit "I'm Gonna Be (500 Miles)" from their second album "Sunshine On Leith". Also, too, a seven year gap of no music between 1994-2001 could have easily killed any other artist's career.
No, these guys are different. As unique as their music, though they are often compared to The Everly Brothers for lack of imagination. I find them to be more like The Kingston Trio--shouting their opinions and views in clever and sometimes humorous ways.
Their eighth album "Notes & Rhymes" follows in the same tradition as 2007's "Life With You" and 2005's "Restless Soul". Slick production, full band, and half an album's worth of good material. Every Proclaimers' album has several good songs on it, but they also tend to have half a disc's worth of mediocre songs. The same is true here. The Proclaimers are never bad, but they can be boring at times.
The best songs here are the Adam Ant, "Goody Two Shoes" beat of the title track, the first single "Love Can Move Mountains", "Three More Days", "Just Look Now", "Sing All Our Cares Away" and "I Know". The rest is just average. I keep hoping that The Proclaimers will shed their 1960's sounds and get more modern, or maybe go back to their roots with an acoustic album like their debut. I guess I will have to wait at least another two years.
Here's how "Notes & Rhymes" compares to their previous work:
1987 This Is The Story: Four Stars
1988 Sunshine On Leith: Five Stars
1994 Hit The Highway: Three and a Half Stars
2001 Persevere: Three and a Half Stars
2003 Born Innocent: Two and a Half Stars
2005 Restless Soul: Three and a Half Stars
2007 Life With You: Three Stars
2009 Notes & Rhymes: Three Stars