4.0 out of 5 stars
Not Floyd, but excellent., Jun 9 2004
This review is from: Now Here is Nowhere (Audio CD)
Let me get this out of the way first: I do not think this album sounds particularly like Pink Floyd, and I certainly do not find their drummer to be a classic rock throwback as I have read a lot of places. Yes, there are certain tracks, especially track 3 (which has very Floyd-esque guitars) and track 6 (which has an overall Floyd "sound", whatever that means really) that will make you think of Floyd, but their overall sound is very, very different. More than anything, they just really know how to create a sonic landscape, which is something I think a lot of people associate with Pink Floyd, and therefore find these two bands comparable. I don't really see it. The guitars are not like Pink Floyd at all. Likewise the lyrics. And the singer's voice... totally different. The drums are way too heavy to be Floyd. So, there, thats out of the way.
If I had to compare them to some other bands, I would say they are more Ok Computer and Airbag/How am I Driving-era Radiohead than anything else. They also remind me of Lake Trout, who have a definite Floyd/Radiohead thing going on. More recently they sound very much to me like the new Muse cd. I suppose they sound more like that than anything else I can think of right now.
And thats a good thing. Muse's new cd, Absolution, is far and away my favorite new cd of the year. The more I listen to Now here is Nowhere, the higher it gets on my list, but I think Muse is more solid all the way through. Their album is more cohesive. I think thats another reason why I don't get the Floyd reference with Secret Machines, because as different as Pink Floyd albums are, most of them, at least the great ones (Wish you were Here, the Wall, Dark Side, Animals...) do at least sustain the same sound throughout the album. Even the later ones without Waters manage to do that. This album, on the other hand, sounds extremely different from track to track. I'm not saying thats a bad thing, but I am saying that it doesn't remind me of Floyd.
So here's the deal then. This is an excellent album. I doubt there will be too many cds out this year that are better. But when you listen to it the first time, don't expect to hear Pink Floyd 2. You might be disappointed. I was, and I shouldn't have been, because this is a great cd, and the bands first full-length album as well. I also really think anyone that likes this should pick up Muse, Absolution. And probably give Ok Computer another listen as well, if you've written it off for whatever reason (believe it or not, not everyone likes it). That album is much more Floyd-inspired than I think most people realize.
Stand-out tracks: 1, 3, 5, 6
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Outstanding modern music, May 18 2004
This review is from: Now Here is Nowhere (Audio CD)
Just three guys huh?
Hmmm...sounds like an army at times.
A disciplined and focused army.
Good record.
Very good record.
I'm 53 and I live for music like this...it's why I still listen for new sounds and new approaches.
Yeah, there are still new approaches to be discovered.
You may not think this is anything new, but I do, and that's why I like it.
One of the reasons.
It rocks, it soothes, and it affects.
Give it a shot...let it rock, soothe, and perhaps affect you.
That's what new music's all about.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Buy this now!, July 19 2004
This review is from: Now Here is Nowhere (Audio CD)
This album, and more importantly, this band, lives up to its well-deserved hype. "Now Here is Nowhere" is comprised of spacey, neo-psychedelic rock ala Pink Floyd, Led Zep, later-day Flaming Lips, with a dash of the early Verve. The songs were written to flow, and the CD harkens back to a time when bands made LP's, not just singles. If you have a chance, see these guys live; they will blow you away! I've seen them twice at the Black Cat in D.C., and cannot wait to see them again. Live, they are on par with Sonic Youth, if not better. I would not be going out on a limb by saying that they are akin to a modern version of Cream. If you were to buy this album now, and see them live, you would make two choices you will not regret. The members are great guys, and they make intense and exciting music. Enjoy-
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No