Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
LIFE BEHIND THE LENNON CURTAIN, Mar 25 2001
John Lennon was a brilliant, talented and very complex man. This book explores his on-again, off-again relationship with his first child, Julian, born 4/8/63. Apparently wanting more of a paternal relationship with his oldest son, John tries to make up for this by being a full time father to his second son, Sean (b. 10/9/75). His love and seemingly dependent relationship with Yoko is also discussed; in reading this work as with many others on John Lennon one gets the feeling that he is rather dependent upon her. Towards the end of his life John learns to sail; this single accomplishment appears to symbolize a step towards independence. He takes to this new ability immediately and wants to share all he has learned with Sean. Inclusion appears to be the theme of this latter period in his life; he includes Yoko on many of his songs; some of Yoko's works appear on his albums. On the 1980 "Double Fantasy" collection, John does many self-revealing songs, such as his poignant "Beautiful Boy," a song he wrote for Sean and "Clean Up Time," a song about the roles he and Yoko have in running their business. Yoko's "Beautiful Boys," which was written for John and Sean is a very peaceful song. It really is a good song and it is interesting that the title is very similar to the one John did for Sean. This book describes and reveals a very complex man, a very brilliant man, a very tortured man and at core a very private man. Who knows today what John Lennon would have created had he not died in 1980? The death of John Lennon on 12/8/80 remains one of the worst days in my life and a day that will be etched in infamy for time immemorial. Imagine John Lennon today. Imagine John, Sean and Yoko now. The world will always wonder and Imagine.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Must for all Who loved Lennon or were interested in him., Dec 3 2000
Anyone who liked (or loved) anything about the Beatles would enjoy this book. I would recommend it to anyone and particularly those who as I, grew up in a time when their wonderful, and sometimes controversial songs and lyrics were first winning us over on the airwaves of America. John was always at the forefront of all the controversy and we will always wonder... "What If?" I feel he still had a lot to offer the world and this book takes us through the last days of his life and gives us a look that we might never have imagined. He was a complex man and this book helps us to see inside him in a way that we never thought about before, and puts in perspective the tragedy that ended any hopes of a reconciliation that all "Fab Four" fans dreamed of. To the person who wrote the review as copied below, I'd like to say to you, first of all you could have used your spell check. Your letter has so many typos one wonders just why you are even trying to write a review, albeit a short on. Also you claim that George Harrison wrote Nowhere Man and not John Lennon. The credits for this song go to John Lennon and Paul McCartney. Go look it up. Worst Book Ever!, November 28, 2000 Reviewer: A reader from Somehwerw This book is just a bunch of lies. If I could rate this book 0 stars I would, but the computer makes you rate it 1 star and up. I think Robert Rosen should read Geoffrey Giuliano's books. Maybe he will get some sense knoked into him. P.s. The son "Nowhere Man" was written by George Harrison, not John Lennon.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
He became what he hated and sought to change...but too LATE., Sep 17 2001
I thought about this book for days after finishing it. There are books on the Beatles as a group and individually...and then there are show biz books on the pitfalls of fame. This SUPERB book shows that his last years of his life, contrary to conventional wisdom, Mr. Lennon didn't live an ideal life -- free of money woes, free to contemplate, write beautiful music, travel, a life filled with hundreds of friends etc. In fact, as Mr. Rosen's GREAT reporting shows, he was worried about his physical appearance, jealous of Sir Paul, lonely, distrustful of people since he felt they wanted to use him, and striving to be a better father and friend to his son Julian. Rosen temporarily had access to Lennon's diaries (which were later taken back) and the book quickly evolves into less a book about Lennon or a Beatle than someone enslaved by fame and fortune: the once rebellious Lennon had become highly materialistic, a boss who almost gleefully hired and fired servants frequently and a person emotionally chained and drained by Yoko. Indeed, the book confirms fans' suspicions that had he not been with Yoko he might have created MORE during his lifetime. With all his wealth, real estate and servants he led a somewhat depressing, hum-drum life, holed up in his apartment, creatively bankrupt until when, towards the end, he recorded Double Fantasy. The irony is that just as he began to lift himself out of his creative and personal slumps, Mark David Chapman started going quickly downhill. This book brilliantly details Chapman's transformation into Lennon's assasin. And it's done with no corn or cliche -- just brilliant reporting that makes you feel the loss even more when it's over. On a personal note, I was working on a newspaper in Kansas (I am now a fulltime ventriloquist) doing night shift the night Lennon was murdered. When the editor on duty said "They shot John Lennon" my reaction was "Was he hurt?" You'll feel the loss AGAIN when you read this -- but this time a SPECIAL LOSS since it was clear he was finally getting his life, priorities, work and relationships on track when he was struck down. EXCELLENT BOOK ON THE PITFALLS OF FAME EVEN IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE BEATLES.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|