4.0 out of 5 stars
REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS!, Jan 13 2012
Spoilers ahead ... you've been warned:
Some people may view Kristin Hannah's books as light, insignificant, 'hausfrau' books, but I personally think she can do wrong. When it comes to crafting stories about human relationships, Hannah is one of the best.
However, there are always exceptions when I say stuff like that.
On Mystic Lake is the story of Annie, who returns to her childhood home, Mystic, after her husband of 20 years, Blake, cheats on Annie and asks her for a divorce when their only daughter, Natalie, leaves for London.
When back in Mystic, Annie meets an old childhood friend, Nick, who has a daughter, Izzy, who became mute after the suicide of her mother, Kathy. Along with spending time with her father, Annie agrees to watch Izzy while Nick is at work. Having led a life where she was the nurturer, caretaker, and supporter, Annie immediately falls in love with Izzy.
There are problems with On Mystic Lake'and they're kind of significant.
The first problem is that the whole point of the story is for Annie to find herself, but she just moves from playing the 'mother and wife' role to her own family, to immediately playing it for another. I would have liked Annie to find some kind of independence along the way.
The second problem is that Annie finds out she's pregnant. With Blake's baby. Even though she wasn't happy with Blake, she gets back together with him and he changes'for a while. After the baby is born, they fall back into their old routine until Blake finally decides that he can't live like this with Annie anymore. Now, after getting rejected TWICE by the same man, does Annie finally decide to go back to Mystic and open her bookstore she's dreamed of, and maybe get back together with Nick (that is, if he isn't already heartbroken'does Annie just assume Nick would wait around and pine over her?).
Despite the obvious flaw, On Mystic Lake was an ok read. Not the best Kristin Hannah book out there, but still a good one. Though, if you really feel you need to get some Kristin Hannah in your life, start with Winter Garden, not On Mystic Lake.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
An absolutely beautiful love story, Nov 13 2003
On 11/11, I endured the funeral of a very dear friend. As I approached the church, I noticed the sun breaking through the clouds, beaming down rays of light to shine down on the building where she lay inside, awaiting the eulogy to be given for her final goodbye. I thought my heart would break and I would never stop crying, even though I finally did. After the funeral, I stopped by my favorite bookstore and purchased four novels, two of which were written by Kristin Hannah. That evening, I made the mistake of starting to read ON MYSTIC LAKE. Because my eyelids were still swollen from the many tears I'd cried at the funeral and during the day, and my eyeballs felt like sandpaper was swiping over them every time I blinked, I thought it best to put the book down and finish reading it later. The next morning I found myself picking the novel up again. After I started to read. I couldn't stop until I'd read the rest of story, nor did I stop crying. I have to believe that Kristin Hannah has the finest talent to write the sweetest of love stories that I've ever had the pleasure to read in this novel. I have another one of her novels, but I don't dare start it right away. I need a break from the tears. KH had no trouble from the very beginning to capture of my attention. I felt every moment of Annie's heartache, as the description of the author's plot and characters was most excellent. If you want a genuine, heartfelt/heartbreaking/happy-ending love story, do this one. Just make sure you have a box of Kleen-x sitting close by. You'll need it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No