37 of 46 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A year in the Colorado life, May 2 2005
By Corinne H. Smith - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: On the Wild Edge: In Search of a Natural Life (Hardcover)
33 years ago, John Denver first sang a warning about Colorado developers trying "to tear the mountains down to bring in a couple more: more people, more scars upon the land." Dave Petersen issues a similar lament in the final chapters of ON THE WILD EDGE. But that's after we have spent a great deal of time in the woods with this likeable and contemporary disciple of Edward Abbey and Aldo Leopold, listening intently and eagerly grabbing every observation he tosses in our direction.
In standard natural history narrative style, Petersen shares a sample year with us. He and his wife Caroline live as simply as possible in a mountain cabin near the city of Durango, Colorado. They raise or find their own food, with Dave the hunter providing meat from a single elk each year. While this lifestyle has immeasurable benefits -- like witnessing a screen-door nose-touch between a bear cub on the porch and the family dog standing inside -- it is not without its pitfalls. Ranking high on that list are the lack of medical insurance and the near-constant verification of the stupidity of mankind. It's not as easy to "simplify" today as it was in Thoreau's time.
Page after page, Petersen teaches us much about the natural world of the Rockies. As far as plants, insects and stars are concerned -- well, their numbers are so many that he admits he doesn't know much about the individuals among them. Give him mammals -- the bigger, the better -- and he can rattle off every one of their habits and preferences. Deer, elk, and bears are among his favorite fellow creatures. And though he hunts, he's conscientious when it comes to aiming his arrow. His behavior and choices mirror that of any other wild predator.
Reading and thinking about this lifestyle provides great environmental joy, but it's also a double-edged sword. This is the kind of book we read and say, "YES! That's the life I've always wanted to lead." But if we all lived it, it would no longer be unique, and the wilderness -- the very thing we'd want to get close to -- would be destroyed in the process. The intelligent tactic for us, then, is to let folks like Dave and Caroline Petersen be the forest dwellers. Let them be the reporters, and we will wistfully read their stories and live vicariously through their experiences. <sigh> It's a difficult but environmentally-conscious choice.
18 of 24 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Yarns of Naturalism, Feb 11 2006
By Richard L. Pangburn - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: On the Wild Edge: In Search of a Natural Life (Paperback)
What a treat! I bought this from Amazon back when it first came out in hardcover, and it has resided on my to-be-read shelf all this time. We now have snow here and, in a wintry mood, I was prompted to pick this one up after finishing Vardis Fisher's excellent THE MOUNTAIN MAN and watching the Robert Redford movie based upon that book.
What a dustjacket! It says here that Caroline Peterson, the author's "permanent wife," took that photo. If the gorgeous, dustjacket art especially appeals to you--as it does to me--then you might also enjoy looking inside at these marvelous tales of David and Caroline Peterson in their natural surroundings.
This author will resonate to those who love the nature writings of Emerson and Thoreau, Doug Peacock and Edward Abbey. Peterson writes with the practical common sense of Wendell Berry mixed with an almost mystical be-here-now sense of wonder. He sees the Great Spirit in things.
We found this a delightful, gorgeous edition to our personal library of naturalism. This author edited A. B. Guthrie's enviromental essays and wrote the afterward to Guthrie's marvelous autobiography. I can't say if this is Peterson's best book because I've yet to read several of his others. They are now moving up on my list.
32 of 44 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
author should stick with nature writing, not politics, Oct 4 2006
By Adam R. Emter "dakotaboy81" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: On the Wild Edge: In Search of a Natural Life (Hardcover)
David Peterson writes very well and has a great ability to engage the reader and make them feel as if they are part of the forest where David writes. I am only about half finished with the book and have enjoyed his views on simple living and self sufficiency. However, his subtle and not-so-subtle interjections about politics totally distract from the beautiful writings about nature. If I wanted political commentary, I would read a book about politics, not a book about nature and simple living.