Most helpful customer reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Unfortunate DVD For A Classic Drama, Jun 26 2003
This review is from: Ordinary People (Widescreen) (DVD)
Let me first say that 5 stars is for the movie ONLY, and NOT the DVD. This release from Paramount Pictures was sure as heck making alot of the film's fans smile, waiting for the DVD for so long. But yet again we've been swindled by another bare-bones DVD release, with only an original theatrical trailer and a 10 scene chapter selection, which seems utterly ridiculous for a two hour movie; I always end up fast-forwarding to the scene I want. The widescreen transfer is not too bad though. I was very happy to find out that this is a clean, TRUE 1.85:1 widescreen picture (I'm thankful it wasn't matted) that favors the right side of the screen. But as for the audio, it's English mono with hiss and pop throughout the picture, which makes the movie experience half-and-half; the picture clean, the audio scratchy. Also, for those movie nuts out there who love watching a movie with Closed Captioning will be dissapointed. They are illegitimate at best, which also makes it unfair for the deaf and hard of hearing to enjoy the movie the way it's meant to be. I happen to get really annoyed when I watch a movie with very slow captioning. So then it looks like this: [Captioning] "After Buck died, dad came into my room. He didn't know what to say. He put his arm around me. We just sat there." [What He Actually Said] "My father came into my room, an-- and he didn't know what to say. This is-- this is right after Buck died. And, uh, he came over and he sat on the bed right next to me, put his arm around my shoulder, and we just sat there." I feel that it kills the emotion of what's being said. It is these kind of DVD releases that make us happy hearing it's coming, and make us dissapointed after the purchase. I'm hoping that Paramount will smarten up in the future and not go forth childishly releasing DVDs with VHS-like quality and lazy Closed Captioning. 2 stars for an OK picture transfer. I just wish it could have been better...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Not an Ordinary Film, April 14 2005
This review is from: Ordinary People (Widescreen) (DVD)
Every once in a while, a film comes along that makes you want to destroy your TV set. This film is it for me. Watching America's sweetheart transform herself into a distant, emotionless, cold woman was almost too much for me. I wanted to throw something at my TV. And I continued to watch, mostly in shock as the story unfolded. The direction was amazing. Robert Redford paced this film to perfection. The score - Pachabel's canon was perfect. The acting was so fantastic, it was unbellievable how believable they were. Timothy Hutton received a well deserved Oscar. Mary Tyler Moore was denied her much deserved oscar for this film. Donald Sutherland and Judd Hirsh put it all together with amazing performances. I just can't say enough; the film left me speechless. It was, in one word, brilliant.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the best films of all time, July 10 2004
Well, this film is easily one of the best I've ever seen. I saw it for the first time around 1981. It was odd, since i was watching with my own dysfunctional family when I was about 14. It's a film that moves you every time you watch it and you can take away something different each time. This is the mark of superb writing, acting and directing. I can't believe that this was Redford's first attempt at directing. It boggles the mind. Just the natural scenes of suburban Chicago alone are well-done. Although Mary Tyler Moore, Sutherland and Hirch do fantastic jobs as Conrad's parents and psychiatrist, trying to get inside his head, it was Hutton's performance as Conrad that moved me most. He portrays the son left behind by a brother who died in a boating accident. When the movie begins, Conrad has just returned to "normal" after being in the hospital for months due to a suicide attempt. It is ironic that the title is "ordinary" people as this family is far from ordinary. But Hutton's performance, with both emotionality and such a sense of emptiness is one of the most vivid performances I've ever seen. What ever happened to Tim Hutton anyway ? Mary Tyler Moore's performance of the cold Beth, who seems to still blame Conrad on her favorite son Buck's death, is impeccable. It really makes sense that you could get performances out of her and Tim Hutton of this caliber since both just lost a relative (she her son and Hutton his father) right before filming. Donald Sutherland really portrays the kind of father everyone wants, let's just admit it. He cares very much about his son ! To the point that he would visit his shrink to learn more about what he's going through. Excellent performance and I still don't know why he wasn't nominated. I could write a short book about this film. Suffice it to say that everyone should see it, despite whether you view your family of origin as dysfunctional or not. We can all relate to certain themes: hiding feelings, being afraid to face pain, facing pain and not knowing what to do with it, loss of friendship, loss of love, "walking on eggshells" in your own home. Ordinary People is an extraordinary film !
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|