Most helpful customer reviews
1.0 out of 5 stars
Polo & Kosinski--A Bad Combo., May 22 2003
Painted Bird is on my all time best book list, so after learning that Kosinski had also written about polo--a sport I play & love, I rushed to read it. However, the main character and the baroque & over-the-top violence of the game and sex with a panoply of individuals who might be found in Joel Peter Witkin's photographs gets tiring, and Fabian always remains abstruse at best. If Kosinski desired to shock the polo world, he acheived it--see the other reviews by polo players below--and I do have to give him kudos for that, the image of the average upper-class WASP professional, or better yet macho South American, who bought the book based on polo content, reading the sex scenes does make me laugh. But in the end I'd recommend staying away from this book both from the perspective of a polo lover and Kosinski fan. There is a great novel to be written around polo, but this ain't it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1.0 out of 5 stars
Polo anyone? Hardly, Dec 18 2002
As another commenter indicated, this book is written by someone who only wished he was a polo player. It's frighteningly inaccurate and I can't believe that one polo player in the world would agree with the presentations (or should I say misrepresentations) provided within the book. But to focus on the pathetic longings of a man who cannot even understand the rudimentary principles and practices of an elegant and beautiful sport that he wishes to focus his novel on is not even enough...no the content of the book is entirely jumbled with ridiculous sexual escapades merely placed in convenient intervals to titillate domesticated bookworms who may find men and women and transvestites and transsexuals sodomizing each other interesting. Fortunately I didn't buy this book and with the cold weather upon us I now have the kindling I need to start the Yule log--so thanks Jerzy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
The Author In Decline., Dec 6 2002
Passion Play was the beginning of the end for Kozinski, although I give him kudos for trying to step outside of the voyueristic existential drifter of his earlier books; he wouldn't have been able to maintain that forever, and it was beginning to have been rehashed one too many times. However, we get Passion Play instead, an ironic title since it seems devoid of passion unlike his earlier works. This is probably due to the self indulgent & elitist setting of the world of polo (Kozinski's new hobby then) being grafted onto situations like earlier Kozinski novels: it's a bad fit since the earlier protagonists were forced into fight while this one has a choice due to his privelege, and he just seems like a cretin while you want him to do something noble. It gives me the impression that the book was rushed by the author in order to prove that he could break out of the loner stance of his previous books, thus it is a vain work of ego, and not worthy of his talent. Too bad, I think if he'd taken more time, a great book would have been produced.. If you want good Kozinski, start with Being There, Steps, Painted Bird or any of the novels before this one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|