Product Details
|
Tag this product(What's this?)Think of a tag as a keyword or label you consider is strongly related to this product.
Tags will help all customers organize and find favorite items. |
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
fortes fortunam iuvare,
By
This review is from: Penguin Classics Rome And Italy (Paperback)
'fortune favours the brave' (Livy 8.29)This edition has an excellent and fascinating introduction by renowned Livy scholar R. M. Ogilvie. The notes are provided at the bottom of the page and are helpful but unobtrusive. Livy is renowned for his prose and even in the translation its beauty sometimes shines through. I didn't compare the translation to the original very often, but the translation is crisp and readable. In Book 6, Livy candidly acknowledges that the reader must feel tired of reading about all the wars the Romans fought with the Volscians and also wonder how the latter always found new men after so many defeats (6.12). This could be said about the Rome's wars in general. The annalistic style and its recounting of short wars can become very repetitive'year after year so and so are elected consuls and they slaughter one army after another. However, when Livy stays with a single narrative for a longer time, the narratives can be evocative and exciting. The story of the Caudine Pass in Book IX, for example, is as gripping as any. Books 5-10 give a sense of how Rome began to grow from one city among many to the seat of an empire. It also shows how seriously the Romans took the will of the gods, and how many people they slaughtered to attain the foundation of their empire. Livy shows Roman expansion in the best light, justifying it through their neighbours' aggression and perfidy. However, he also allows the enemy view to be presented. The Samnites say the Romans are 'a people always greedy for further advances' (9.38). Livy allows another of the Samnites to say: 'you always give your fraud some semblance of legality' (9.11). And the Samnites tell the Etruscans that together they could force the Romans: 'to fight not to maintain their intolerable tyranny over Italy but for their own self-preservation' (10.16). If you are reading Livy because of Machiavelli, this book brings Machiavelli to life in a new way since it makes you realize that his Discourses is truly the Discourses on Livy. I would be tempted to give the book four stars because of its repetitive nature but couldn't considering how influential it has been and how valuable it is as a document of Roman self-understanding.
5.0 out of 5 stars
A dated translation, but still great reading.,
By
This review is from: Penguin Classics Rome And Italy (Paperback)
This volume contains books VI through X of Livy's monumental 120+ volume history of Rome. It covers the time between the sack of the city by the Gauls (c. 396 BCE) and Rome's emergence as the single most powerful state in Italy (c. 293 BCE). Like other Penguin classics, the translation in this volume is just a bit dated and stuffy in tone, but the warmth and vitality of Livy's style shines through nonetheless.One of the benefits to being interested in ancient Rome in particular is that the Romans were such a literate people, and so taken with their own perceived greatness, that they wrote a great deal, and much of this writing has survived down to our own times. Not only does this provide an invaluable window onto the remote past, it also makes for good reading. Livy (and a number of other Roman era authors) can sound remarkably modern in their sentiments, and even casual readers should be pleasantly surprised by the vigor and readability of Livy's prose.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Great Story!,
By
This review is from: Penguin Classics Rome And Italy (Paperback)
The first thing you will notice about Livy; is that this guy really knows how to tell a story. Sure he is a little over the top with his Roman bias, but who cares. Livy turns Roman history into a series of fun to read tales.The reader also becomes somewhat overwhelmed by the almost constant warfare, of the ancient world. These people lived and died by the rule of the sword. Throw in the occasional plague outbreak, civil uprising, crop failure, and you start to get a good idea of how these people lived their lives. Anyone that is interested in political history and military strategy, will find Livy offers lots of examples. There is one section where Livy gets off track, and compares Alexander The Great, to the Roman military machine. He debates whether or not Alexander could have beaten the Romans. The argument ended up sounding like a sports debate, comparing Orr and Gretzky. Over all this was a very informative and enjoyable history.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
Want to see more reviews on this item?
|
Most recent customer reviews |
|