This is such a find, one of the most enjoyable sets I've ever owned. Back in the late '80s, Popeye cartoons from the mid-30s used to be broadcast very early in the morning on local TV. I used to get up at 5 a.m. to tape them by hand, so there would not be any duplicates. I ended up with a 6-hour tape full of my favorite animation. Then I did something really stupid - I found an outfit that put VHS tapes onto DVD. I was to find out later that this is a real racket. People want this, for their grad tapes, weddings, etc. But this place turned out to be bogus. I never saw my tape again. I was so disappointed, as Popeye was my favorite from childhood and wasn't on the air any more.
So, all these years later, I was in a local department store and saw one copy of this set on a shelf, with space all around it. It had only been out for about 3 days. It seemed to be calling to me! I bought it immediately and began to enjoy an experience beyond my old tape.
For one thing, the tape had been "colorized", so it was very hard to see the backgrounds. The black and white was like pencil drawings by a brilliant artist, effective (often providing a 3-D effect) and quirky. I remembered most of the cartoons, but also appreciated the short documentaries dealing with various aspects of the series.
What surprised me most is how often I laughed out loud, at cartoons I had seen when I was 5 years old. Olive Oyl in particular made me laugh, with her noodle-like, elastic arms and legs. Popeye himself was such an unlikely hero - ugly and gruff, with one eye, no teeth (you can clearly see his gums in these early ones), and grotesque forearms.Read more ›
Was this review helpful to you?
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
298 of 305 people found the following review helpful
This Is The Real Thing... At Long Last !!!!April 13 2007
- Published on Amazon.com
This is it, Popeye cartoon fans! We have dreamed about it, wished for it, and hoped for it. Warner Brothers Video, by arrangement with King Features Syndicate, is issuing here the first 60 ORIGINAL Fleischer Studios Popeye cartoons. Wonderful! These fantastic cartoons are being released in chronological order of their theatrical release, FULLY RESTORED from the original negatives in beautiful black and white, UNCUT, with all Paramount titles restored. Volume 1, 1933-1938, is a 4-disc collector's edition. Also included in this release are the first two Three-Color-Technicolor two-reel specials: "Popeye the Sailor Meets Sinbad the Sailor", and "Popeye the Sailor Meets Ali Baba's Forty Thieves". If that isn't enough, 5 hours worth of bonus materials are included: Audio commentaries from Mark Kausler, Jerry Beck, Mark Evanier, and others. More features include restrospectives on Popeye and Max Fleischer, behind the toons featurettes, and bonus shorts.
So many of us remember seeing many of these vintage Popeye shorts when we were kids, and fondly remember the incredible animation from those early Fleischer Studios Popeye's. In 1933, the original Popeye voice was done by William Costello. Sometime in 1935 he was fired and The Sailor Man's voice was taken over by Jack Mercer, who kept at it for the remaining duration of these great cartoons. Remember that wonderful muttering in those early years by Popeye? That was the great Jack Mercer. Who could forget that fantastic "Is that so?" and all the other regular mutterings that Popeye would utter, more so especially during the Fleischer years. Bluto was fantastic, too, with some great back-and-forth quips between himself and his rival. His voice was delivered by William Pennell from 1933-1935, then Gus Wickie from 1935 until his death in 1938. The voice of Olive Oyl was delivered by Mae Questel.
So, all you Popeye fans... this is what we have been waiting for many a year. Throw out all your other Popeye videos and DVDs. Get rid of your VHS tapes that you made from the Cartoon Network. Destroy (with pleasure) all of those horrible colorized Popeye's made infamous by Mr. Turner. Animation historian Jerry Beck says that "your eyes will POP at the restorations. If you've never seen them you are in for a revelation." At long last...the first official release of the Max Fleischer cartoons on DVD. Without a doubt, you will be absolutely, positively delighted!!!
145 of 149 people found the following review helpful
So much more than spinach. . .April 28 2007
- Published on Amazon.com
As a lifelong fan of classic animation, I simply could not be more THRILLED at the prospect of finally owning restored versions of the Fleischer Popeye cartoons. Other reviewers have expertly detailed the contents of this set, so I'd like to take a moment to try and convince/convert those folks who may not know and love these things as much as I do. . .
There has been, as long as I can recall, a misconception about Popeye cartoons. I recently had this discussion with a good friend, who could not understand why I was so excited about this release. She, like so many people, was raised on the color Popeye cartoons made in the 1960's. "They're all the same," she complained. "Popeye and Bluto fight over Olive Oyl, and Popeye eats spinach and beats up his rival. Big deal." And you know something? Based solely on the cartoons my friend had seen, she was right. She knew nothing of these original black & white gems made by the Fleischers beginning in the early 1930's. And while the voice of Popeye in most of those shorts is the same (Jack Mercer) as the later ones, that's where the similarities end. The early 'toons are full of creative gags, ad-libs and boundless energy. Plus, they have the inimitable Fleischer style, which can also be found in Betty Boop and, later, the first Superman cartoons.
I hope that those of you who only know Popeye from the later, bland incarnations will check out this set. Forget Poopdeck Pappy or Popeye's nephews (those these will eventually surface in the Fleischer versions); this is the REAL POPEYE in all his elastic, mumbling glory.
Essential viewing for Popeye enthusiasts, and anyone interested in the early history of animated sound cartoons.
P.S. I wish I could get back all the money I've blown on cheapskate VHS and DVD versions by Goodtimes, etc. Those things are headed for a garage sale faster than you can say "I yam what I yam!"
93 of 95 people found the following review helpful
Here's everything you get -- and the top five reasons to buy itJuly 31 2007
- Published on Amazon.com
Well, blow me down! As a Disney writer, I didn't think I'd like these competing cartoons from the golden age of Mickey Mouse. But I was wrong! Like the best early Mickey shorts, these Popeye cartoons are truly entertaining and funny, with boundless energy and many creative gags. Whether you're a classic animation fan or just someone looking for something different, here are five reasons you should buy this set:
1. All of the cartoons are from Popeye's original Fleischer Bros. incarnation, when the series had its most cockamamie characters (including the Sailor Man in all his gruffy, mumbling glory), cockeyed plots, fluid animation and detailed backgrounds.
2. The shorts are the original, black-and-white, uncut versions, fully restored from the master negatives and never before made available to the public.
3. Unlike the more familiar 1950-1960s Popeye cartoons, these don't all have the same plot! Yes, Bluto tries to kiss Olive Oyl in a couple, but otherwise the stories on this set jump all over the place. In one ("Lost and Foundry"), Baby Swee'pea saves Popeye and Olive from being crushed.
4. Each disc comes with a full slate of extras, including documentaries, featurettes and rare bonus cartoons, most of which are early silent films and ten of which star Koko the Clown. Altogether there are more than five hours of bonus features.
5. Ten cartoons have audio commentaries, featuring film and animation experts such as Jerry Beck and Leonard Maltin.
Here's a complete rundown on what you get:
DISC 1 1. "Popeye the Sailor" (1933) (with commentary)' 2. "I Yam What I Yam" (1933)' 3. "Blow Me Down!" (1933)' 4. "I Eats My Spinach" (1933)' 5. "Seasin's Greetinks!" (1933)' 6. "Wild Elephinks" (1933) (with commentary)' 7. "Sock-a-Bye, Baby" (1934) (with commentary)' 8. "Let's You and Him Fight" (1934)' 9. "The Man on the Flying Trapeze" (1934)' 10. "Can You Take It" (1934) (with commentary)' 11. "Shoein' Hosses" (1934)' 12. "Strong to the Finich" (1934)' 13. "Shiver Me Timbers!" (1934)' 14. "Axe Me Another" (1934)' 15. "A Dream Walking" (1934) (with commentary)
Bonus features on Disc 1 include a feature on early animation ("Mining the Strip, Elzie Segar and Thimble Theatre"), a 43-minute documentary on Popeye's early career ("I Yam What I Yam: The Story of Popeye the Sailor") and a profile on Olive Oyl ("Me Fickle Goyl, Olive Oyl: The World's Least Likely Sex Symbol"). Bonus silent cartoons from other studios (all based on comic strips) include "Colonel Heeza Liar at the Bat" (1915), the Mutt and Jeff short "Domestic Difficulties" (1916) and "Krazy Kat Goes A-Wooing" (1916).
DISC 2 16. "The Two-Alarm Fire" (1934) 17. "The Dance Contest" (1934)' 18. "We Aim to Please" (1934) 19. "Beware of Barnacle Bill" (1935) (with commentary)' 20. "Be Kind to 'Aminals'" (1935) 21. "Pleased to Meet Cha!" (1935) 22. "The 'Hyp-Nut-Tist'" (1935) (with commentary)' 23. "Choose Your 'Weppins'" (1935) (with commentary)' 24. "For Better or Worser" (1935) (with commentary)' 25. "Dizzy Divers" (1935)' 26. "You Gotta Be a Football Hero" (1935)' 27. "King of the Mardi Gras" (1935)' 28. "Adventures of Popeye" (1935)' 29. "The Spinach Overture" (1935)' 30. "Vim, Vigor and Vitaliky" (1936)
Extras on Disc 2 include a 30-minute historical documentary with lots of clips, "Forging the Frame: The Roots of Animation 1900-1920," the featurette "Sailor's Hornpipes: The Voices of Popeye," a profile on Wimpy ("Wimpy the Moocher: Ode to the Burgermeister") and three more silent shorts: "Bobby Bumps Puts a Beanery on the Bum" (1918), the Felix the Cat cartoon "Feline Follies" (1919) and "The Tantalizing Fly" (1919) with Koko the Clown.
DISC 3 31. "A Clean Shaven Man" 32. "Brotherly Love" 33. "I Ski - Love Ski - You Ski" (with commentary) 34. "Bridge Ahoy!" 35. "What - No Spinach?" 36. "I Wanna Be a Lifeguard" 37. "Let's Get Movin'" 38. "Never Kick A Woman" 39. "Little Swee'pea" 40. "Hold the Wire" 41. "The Spinach Roadster" 42. "Popeye the Sailor Meets Sindbad the Sailor" (double-length, color, with commentary) 43. "I'm in the Army Now" 44. "The Paneless Window Washer" 45. "Organ Grinder's Swing"
Disc 3 bonus features consist of two featurettes, "Blow Me Down! The Music of Popeye" and "Popeye in Living Color: A Look at the Color Two-Reelers" and six early Out of the Inkwell shorts with Koko the Clown: "Modeling" (1921), "Invisible Ink" (1921), "Bubbles" (1922), "Jumping Beans" (1922), "Bed Time" (1923) and "Trapped" (1923).
DISC 4 46. "My Artistical Temperature" 47. "Hospitaliky" 48. "The Twisker Pitcher" 49. "Morning, Noon and Night Club" 50. "Lost and Foundry" (with commentary) 51. "I Never Changes My Altitude" 52. "I Likes Babies and Infinks" 53. "The Football Toucher Downer" 54. "Proteck the Weakerist" (with commentary) 55. "Popeye the Sailor Meets Ali Baba's Forty Thieves" (double-length, color, with commentary) 56. "Fowl Play" 57. "Let's Celebrake" 58. "Learn Polikeness" 59. "The House Builder Upper" 60. "Big Chief Ugh-Amugh-Ugh"
Bonus features on Disc 4 include profiles on Swee'pea and Bluto ("Me Lil' Swee'pea: Whose Kid is He Anyway?" and "Et Tu Bluto? Cartoondom's Heaviest Heavy"), three more Out of the Inkwell Koko shorts ("A Trip to Mars" (1924), "Koko Trains 'Em" (1925) and "Koko Back Tracks" (1927)) and a two-minute follow-the-bouncing-ball oddity "Let's Sing with Popeye" (1934).
To sum up, this set is a real treat for any cartoon buff and a must-have for any student of animation or pop culture. But beyond all that, it's just plain fun.
73 of 78 people found the following review helpful
The REAL Deal - Popeye Is BACK IN BLACK (& WHITE)!!May 22 2007
- Published on Amazon.com
The original Fleischer Studios Popeye cartoons were groundbreaking. The animation had a near 3-D look to them as the backgrounds were amazingly detailed and shaded. For the Popeye animated shorts Max and Dave Fleischer created a great urban world for Popeye to live in (although they did occasionally change the locales depending on story needs). There was a reality to the concrete jungle that was seen onscreen.
Then there were the voice actors, the most recognizable being Jack Mercer as Popeye (he took over the role in 1935) and Gus Wickie as Bluto (who also took over that role in 1935). Both of these voice actors left such an indelible mark on the series that whenever a viewer watches one of the shorts made before they took over their roles (or after Wickie's death in 1938) it just doesn't sound, "right." Wickie's deep voice, in particular, was so unique to the role that the Fleischers didn't even try to replace him with a "sound-alike," but rather went in a different direction.
Included in this set are many of the best Popeye cartoons (but by no means all of the best - there were many great animated shorts to come!), including, "The Paneless Window Washer," "Let's Get Movin," "Lost and Foundry," and, of course, the classic color Popeye, "Epic," "Popeye the Sailor Meets Sindbad the Sailor!"
Warner Brothers has restored these animated works of art back to their original glory. It is said that the picture quality on these cartoons will result in, "Shock and awe," as these shorts haven't been seen in this good condition since they were first shown.
This is clearly the set that Popeye enthusiasts have been waiting for. The best news is that it is but the first in a series of releases from Warner Brothers which will eventually include ALL of the classic Popeye cartoons! Way to go Warners!
-Update: This set is even better than expected. The extra features are very good and the shorts themselves look fantastic. One of the best DVD releases of 2007.
30 of 32 people found the following review helpful
REMASTERED! UN-CUT, COMPLETE! AWESOME B & W PRINTS! FOR TRUE POPEYE FANS!!April 17 2007
- Published on Amazon.com
(PREVIEW)-Finally on July 31, 2007 retailing for around $64.92. This will be a 4 disc dvd set, Vol 1 , NTSC Format,COMPLETELY REMASTERED, COMPLETELY UN-CUT (with paramont logo intros), 58 BLACK & WHITE, (Two color),Run Time 550 minutes, From 1933-1938. The first 60 original Max Fleischer animated cartoons! Popeye fans have long awaited this awesome news to finally own ,'' in my opinon'', the BEST classic animation ever created! This is a Warners Home Videos release, filled with over 5 hours of bonus material, including audio commentaries by Mark Kausler, Eric Goldberg, John k, Leslie Cabarga,Mark Evanier,etc.Also included '' I Yam What I Yam'' Story of Popeye. Bonus Popeye shorts including'' Let's sing with Popeye '' and Popular Science, making of Popeye cartoons at Fleischer Studios, and much, much more! Also one color Betty Boop ''Poor Cindrella'' cartoon. This dvd set is a Popeye fans dream come true release! So don't forget to mark your calenders JULY 31 2007!