5.0 out of 5 stars
Irvine exposed- the fascinating birth and gowth of a planned city!, Aug 2 2011
By S. Gillespie - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Postsuburban California: The Transformation of Orange County since World War II (Paperback)
This is a great history of Orange County and especially the establishment and the growth of the Irvine Company and how the city of Irvine itself was planned and functions even to this day! Whether you like Irvine or hate it I believe you will find this book a fascinating read.
3.0 out of 5 stars
A Collection of Studies on Post Suburban Orange County, Jun 25 2011
By M. Quan - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Postsuburban California: The Transformation of Orange County since World War II (Paperback)
The premise of the book is about Orange County as an example of postsuburban communities that concepts of urban, rural and suburban don't accurately define. No longer rural and a part of Los Angeles County, Orange County has emerged in its own right, with a population and economy outpacing most states, that defies the concept of Orange County as just another suburb. However its decentralized urban structure, with many focal cities, contrasts the traditional concepts of an obvious centerpoint.
That is what the book is supposedly about. The book is actually a collection of research papers from multiple authors that are somewhat supporting of the overarching theme. Some chapters are brilliant, backed by hard data, while a few of the more qualitative arguments are noticeably lacking. After reading an LA Times article stating that families in Orange County are more traditional (husband, wife, two kids, no divorce) than the rest of California, I was hoping for more. Also disappointing is the hinted division of older North Orange County versus newer South Orange County. Moreover for an area that has changed so much since the end of WWII, I would have expected more dedicated to the transformation of farm land. The lack of a single author, providing one clear overarching depiction of Orange County then and now, is a considerable weakness.
The least you should know though is the copyright date (1991). This book is over 20 years old which will not encompass the two great political events in Orange County of the 1990's; the decommissioning of El Toro and the 1994 bankruptcy. While most of the trends are still applicable the numbers are very dated.