8 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
anything chomsky rates 5 stars ...., Jun 13 2003
This review is from: Power And Terror: Noam Chomsky In Our Times (Dvd) (DVD)
I viewed this MOVIE at the time, at its western
hemispheric debut, in Palo Alto, CA and was
disappointed in its craftsmanship as a movie and
a documentary. It felt like almost a home movie
presentation of Chomsky lecturing.
I have to recommend "Manufacturing Consent" as a
superior effort, but as I say in the review title,
anything "Chomsky" gets a 100% in my book. I would
see him in lecture, or any movie that was made about
him.
Noam Chomsky reads and digests books at the rate most
of us go through oxygen. He wrote his first book when
he was a child, and developed a very egalitarian,
democratic uniquely American, and possibly as much
Anti-American (a term he says only has meaning in
extremely totalitarian societies, and has much fun
with as he toys with the idea of Anti-Italianism)
but Chomsky is a rugged idealist, individualist,
without the contempt for the average working folk
and the experience to know what he is talking about.
I am not a liberal or conservative, but I do like facts
and I like to listen to people who know them, understand
them and can enlighten me about their view of the facts.
Chomsky is one person who, whether or not you agree with
him, which I do on most things, but do not on some major
issues, will - if you are willing to listen with an open
mind give you the free benefit of his incredible moral and
encyclopaedic knowledge, and wisdom. Having won as Nobel
prize in Linguistics qualifies him in my mind as well as
one who can abstract ideas and meaning at least as well
and as validly and any human on our planet and qualifies
him as one all of us in the world owe a listen to at least
once.
This man is a national treasure. This is where Power and
Terror is meaningful to me, in just recording Chomsky's
words appearances this movie is important. Where it fails
in my view is that it is too choppy, does not go into
Chomsky's philosphy deeply on any one issue, and does not
challenge Chomsky. In this way it reminded me of a first
effort in cinemetography of hero worship.
If one really wants to see the brilliance and multi-
dimensionality of Chomsky, Manufacturing Consent is better
for that. Power and Terror whets one's appetite for more
Chomsky, more truth, and raw discussion, which to me is
very important and very missing in our national debate.
Personally, I feel any media attention Chomsky can get
is good, so I urge people to see or buy anything that
features his point of view. This man is mischaracterized,
villified, insulted and demeaned by the right-wing radio
host such as Rush Limbaugh, Michael Savage, etc, men who
name-call and attack the person. If you are even honest
and right wing, and you think you believe what the right
says about Chomsky, then you at least owe it to yourself
to hear what he says and consider it before you pass
judgement.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1.0 out of 5 stars
Pathetic Attempt at Filmaking, Jun 20 2004
This review is from: Power And Terror: Noam Chomsky In Our Times (Dvd) (DVD)
Don't waste your money on this DVD. It is incredibly quixotic in its aims and painfully tedious to follow. Chomsky seems incredibly out of touch, especially considering many of his positions. But even if you agree with him, this DVD isn't likely to enthral you either. He tries to directly connect terrorism and the larger issue of power without actually dealing with each issue. The viewer is left to ask "What is terror to Chomsky?" and "Whose power, where?" and "What the heck is this guy getting at?" He could clear things up and liven the DVD up and it still would seem bluntly ineffective. I've never given a one-star review before, but I'd give this zero stars if it was an option.
Simply put, this DVD leaves you wondering why you just spent a good chunk of a day watching Chomsky ramble on about conspiracy theories.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No