1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Okay, but full of bias and errors, July 31 2003
This review is from: A Practical Approach To Strength Training (Paperback)
To begin, Brzycki is not what I'd call "the strength and conditioning coach" at Princeton. His function at Princeton for many years has apparently been primarily in fitness administration and teaching some fitness classes, not the strength and conditioning of athletes. According to one interview, Brzycki hasn't trained athletes on a regular basis for quite some time. According to another interview, Brzycki did not apply his own "practical approach" to his own workouts until after well his days as a competitive powerlifter were over.
In other words, Brzycki is a fitness expert, not necessarily a strength expert. In the field of fitness he probably excels. Otherwise, in my opinion, he often tries to force-fit his fitness theories into strength training principles. Fitness goals and strength training goals are not necessarily the same. Brzycki has far less DIRECT experience training strength athletes than many other authors - Dreschler, Poloquin, Kono, Newton, Zatsiorski, for example. Brzycki shows extreme prejudice against Olympic-style weightlifting, for example, a strength and power sport he has never, to my knowledge, either competed in nor coached. Sour grapes, I suspect. Brzycki apparently reads a lot of scientific journals and must be a fast typist, for he publishes books and articles quite often. Apparently he hasn't read the decades of strength training information and scientific analysis gleaned from the detailed training logs of generations of Communist bloc athletes, which Brzycki dismisses in his first chapter as mere "anecdotal evidence."
That said, if your goal is general fitness with an eye towards increasing strength, then you could do a lot worse than this book. There are many approaches towards strength training that work (and some that don't.) Brzycki's approach will work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
BUY IT NOW!!!, Aug 24 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: A Practical Approach To Strength Training (Paperback)
IF UR INTERESTED IN KNOWING WHY I SHOULD THAT EXERCISE OR IN WHICH WAY -THAT UR TRAINER CANT REALLY ANSWER YOU SOMETIMES- THIS IS THE BOOK. THE ONLY BAD THING IS THAT THEORIES IN THIS BOOK CAN BE CONFUSING IN ORDER FOR U TO MAKE AN EXERCISE PLAN TO USE IN GYM OR UR DIET PLAN.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not for trainers!, Aug 20 2002
This review is from: A Practical Approach To Strength Training (Paperback)
Brzycki starts up by saing more science in weigth training is needed. This book is full of theories with backed up with so calld science! I can use a few example. No 1- You can't increase your balance by doing balance exercises! All athletes and trainers that has some experience in training knows that thats not true. Only because science haven't been able to prove it, it dozen't mean it do not work. Steroides didn't work accordingly to science some years ago. But everyone else knew in the training world. No 2- You don't need to train stability exercises for stability muscles because those muscles get exercised in stabel machine exercises. Let a gymnast run and let a runner do balancing acts that a gymnast do. The gymnast will have no problem but the runner will not be able to dublicate the movement. Use your brain when you read this book because it has som good points but also some ... Brzycki has high understanding of training my hat of to him. But he misses some vital points. To use Mike Mentzers point a view and A. Jones as proven science to back up his claimes please. Maybe it's here in Sweden were science is science. But this is a good HIT book, just not a good training manual for athlets and trainers.
Buy a book by Paul Cheek or NSCA book Essential of strength training and conditioning. Why not buy all three books and get a broader perspectiv on weight training.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No