1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Profiler - technically flawed, Mar 30 2009
This review is from: Profiler:S1 (DVD)
Profiler: Season One
Loved this series, back when it first ran on TV, and was excited to find it available on DVD. Still love the characters, the actors, the horror, the ongoing mystery of Jack. But - over the years, I had forgotten the one thing that drove me crazy watching it originally on TV - the really horrible sound quality! The two main characters, Sam and Bailey, talk as if they had swollen tongues. The actors are desperately in need of speech lessons, and I was dismayed to find that there are no captions or subtitles! Even replaying most of the scenes over and over doesn't help. A great series spoiled by technical indifference.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
great concept, entertaining hiccups, May 20 2010
This review is from: Profiler:S1 (DVD)
As a precursor to the now standard "serial killer" procedural (i.e. CSI, Criminal Minds etc.), Profiler is still the best, with its inventive dark style, engaging camera work, and strong female lead. Admittedly, I had to wait a decade plus to get past the first few episodes (and the laughable over-the-top alpha males), but once the production gelled (disc 2), each episode added further creativity to an already great concept. Unfortunately, the dvd audio quality is poor, requiring intermittent volume adjustments (and no closed captions), but as bonus features there are two commentaries on the pilot, plus some minimal bios and a worthwhile episode of American Justice (Profiles of Evil: Inside the Criminal Mind).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Review & Clearing-up Errors in Amazon's Staff Review, July 11 2004
This review is from: Profiler:S1 (DVD)
I have to take issue with Amazon's Editorial reviewer Jeff Shannon, and his review of Profiler Season I.
Mr. Shannon attempts to review not the DVD itself, but what he *thinks* are the behind-the-scenes truths of the Profiler production. One, he refers to the DVD commentary of Ally Walker - suggesting that she is in fact giving the reason why she left after only "two" seasons. (Psssst, Jeff... it was after THREE seasons - not to mention she headlines the opener of the fourth season).
Then he gives more of his "insight" when he suggests that NBC was troubled by the "miscasting" of Ally Walker. Well, not that I believe Mr. Shannon has any reliable inside information, but what does that have to do with reviewing this DVD? I tend to think that Shannon was insinuating his own feelings about Walker, and trying to use the NBC network - based on rumor - as a way to reinforce them. A more candid review would have read, "I wasn't terribly impressed with Walker, and felt she was miscast in the role."
But that probably wouldn't have held-up against the enormous fan-following of Walker on this show (or as Shannon understated in his review, "growing popularity"), nor would it have stood up well against the fact that after Walker left and was replaced by Jamie Luner, the ratings pretty much tanked.
Make no mistake about it: this is a GREAT show. You will esecially enjoy this Season I DVD. The isolated, episodic stories are each fantastic in their own right, and the Jack thread is very addictive. Ally Walker's performance is compelling, and she leads a solid cast - notably Robert Davi, Peter Frechette, Julian McMahon, and Roma Maffia. You'll watch Season I, and you will RUN to grab Season II.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No