5 of 6 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Powerful conclusion to an amazing series, Aug 16 2009
By J. Shurin "carnivore" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Punisher Max - Volume 5 (Hardcover)
Ennis' latest run on Punisher is one of the highlights of the last decade in comics writing - perhaps its only comparison is Bendis' ground-breaking run on Daredevil. From the first issue, Ennis redefined, modernized and revitalized one of Marvel's most difficult characters. The Punisher became human, frighteningly sane and indescribably scary. Ennis moved him from a four-color 'bullets never kill' world to a nasty, lethal, intrigue-punctuated, chaotic analogue of the real world - and the Punisher changed from a B-list to something very special.
Despite the ultra-violence, Ennis made this latest Punisher a serious figure (although his goofier, earlier run on Punisher is also worth investigating). Like his work with Preacher, the Punisher was a means of identifying and exploring serious themes - bringing order out of chaos, the limits of sanity, morality vs necessity, and even a bit of old-fashioned Americana.
In this last collection (actually two collections combined), these themes come to their conclusions. The Punisher's nastiest foe - the Barracuda - returns, and Frank is faced with a villain as clever and as resourceful as he is. Barracuda is the unstoppable force for Frank Castle's immovable object, and the clash between them is truly epic (and not a single super-power is involved...). In a surprising revelation, the Punisher is forced to think about what really matters to him, especially with Barracuda looming...
In the final volume, Valley Forge, Ennis takes an interesting tangent. The government is finally, seriously, out to bring in Frank Castle. By preying on his weakness - his patriotism - they hope to capture or kill him... with soldiers. The Punisher is again caught between what he believes and the horrible facts of his existence. What will and won't he do to stay on the loose? Although not as action-packed as many of the previous storylines, Valley Forge is perhaps the best-written. Ennis has a flair for 'war stories' - for capturing the emotion of soldiers and veterans alike. 'Valley Forge' is a daring, powerful way of ending his run on the series, and I pity the unfortunate writer that has to follow in his footsteps...
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
More Gritty And Awesome Punisher!!, Dec 16 2009
By Daniel W. Warren - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Punisher Max - Volume 5 (Hardcover)
I still recall vividly opening my first Punisher Max volume and being amazed. This was how Punisher should have been like all along. No crazy high-tech gimmicks or cartoony stories, just a man scarred deeply by the deaths of his family and reaping bloody vengeance.
The art is superb, and I truly feel they captured the true essence of the Punisher. He is a man driven solely by His War and allows no room for compromise of any sort. Understandably, he is most assuredly psychotic, but to him, to sit back and do nothing is insanity in itself. You can't help but to admire a man with that sort of resolve.
If you've read the other Max Volumes, then you'll enjoy this. If you haven't, I would still recommend this book.
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Punisher goes out with a lesser bang than I thought, July 9 2009
By Joseph R. Mcconnell - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Punisher Max - Volume 5 (Hardcover)
*Spoilers below*
This being the last Punisher book for Garth Ennis, I had thought the series would end in some spectacle. Reading the whole thing, I left the series in disappointment. The first story to me was the best of the whole thing. Barracuda returns to try his hands again at Frank Castle, this time coming better prepared and packing a rage for his lost eye and fingers and being shot and left for the sharks. This story was interesting because it gave you a background as to why Barracuda has become a cold-hearted killer (which is an abusive father and bullies). Sadly, at the end of the story, Barracuda takes a last stand at an elementary school and ends up dying by the Punisher (going away with a ripped off nose, ripped off left cheek, and a cut off arm). The seond story is where ex- military men plan to take the Punisher alive to prison. They do this believing that he won't harm them because they are military. This was the case until he kills them at the end without any explanation as to why (maybe I missed it). There are certain breaks in the story where you read parts of a novel for Vietnam made from the son of Stevie (guy who was bayoneted at the end of the paperback "The Punisher: Born". I didn't think the inclusion of the novel was neccesary, as it didn't fit with the main storyline. Overall, I don't want to discourage any one from buying this, but I must say that Garth ended his series in a whisper instead of a bang.