10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Wait for the next edition, Oct 24 2011
By Tyler - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Rails 3 in Action (Paperback)
While I love the effort the authors put forward in writing this book, it just isn't quite finished.
There are MANY (20+) places in the book where following along line-by-line will cause breakages, and you will be left to figure out how to get to the place you need to go. This ends up being a bit of a problem solving exercise in and of itself, but I don't think that's what the authors had in mind.
Bottom line: wait for the second edition. Hopefully by then the authors will actually go through and follow their own tutorial!
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
Very disappointing., Oct 27 2011
By A. Yayalar - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Rails 3 in Action (Paperback)
You would expect a much better book from these authors. Unfortunately It is full of errors, typos, even outdated examples. The book claims to be updated for 3.1. Not quite. Feels rushed out.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Pleased with the book. Pleased with the author. Publisher? Meh., Mar 30 2012
By Joe "professional web developer" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Rails 3 in Action (Paperback)
I have been toying with Rails for several years, and finally decided to get serious about about 4, maybe 6 months ago. I browsed this book, and dug the approach it took, so I bought both the physical book and the ebook.
The book walks you through the development of an app, step by step, and most importantly, includes testing. This is a subject that most books gloss over with, "normally you would write tests for this", or "in the real world you would probably want to write test". Some of the better books may devote a chapter, but don't really give you practical experience in writing tests as you go.
The approach the book takes is nice too in that it does just enough hand-holding. You're given step-by-step instructions when you need them, and referred back to previous reading if you should have learned something already. It starts with pretty basic topics, and works its way through to more advanced topics.
I would recommend going through the book, doing a couple of apps on your own, and then going through the book again to "get it". Well worth the read.
While the book does have a lot of errors, it also has a great support community behind it. Every problem I ran in to I was able to quickly find a solution to on the book's forum.
My problem is with the publisher. One of the reasons I bought the ebook was that, well, ebooks can be updated! No errors! Maybe with other publishers, but apparently not with Manning. Very weird. The cost can be that great. Tech readers expect it, but Manning doesn't get it.