17 of 18 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Smart Da Vinci Code, July 28 2006
By A. D. Crist - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Resurrection (Hardcover)
This is a story about greed, ambition, misogyny, and human nature. Set against the confusing clarity of war, this story takes place between the end of WWII and the beginning of the Arab-Israeli Conflict in 1948. British nurse, Gemma Bastian receives two letters from her Egyptologist father. One letter is full of exciting news of riches and the promise of a new home in Egypt, far away from war-torn London, while the other is addressed to both Gemma and a man she has never met. Shortly after receiving those letters she finds out that her father has died under mysterious circumstances. Gemma travels to Egypt to figure out what happened to her father and why mysterious and threatening men seem to be very interested in his findings.
The main plot in the story has to do with the controversial papyri, known as the Gnostic Gospels, found in Egypt, that are believed to be the lost gospels from apostles of Jesus Christ, including the gospels of Mary Magdalene. This is a fictionalized account of how they disappeared and why they remained hidden for nearly 30 years after their discovery. Resurrection purports that the bible is a case of the winners writing history and eliminating ideas that they did not agree with, namely the role of women and the church in religion. Resurrection is a thought provoking page turner that makes you question the nature of organized religion.
Anyone who was interested in the questions raised in the Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code, but disappointed by the story, will love Resurrection. This book is what The Da Vinci Code could have been if you took out all of the excessive cross-Europe chases and biblical dynasties. There are no secretive, evil religious organizations. No creepy albino monks lurking about after the main characters. Resurrection is a suspenseful love story peopled with a mix of fictional and historical characters. Tucker Malarkey's characters are a bit wooden, but they are (perhaps inadvertently) secondary to the intriguing religious debate. She has created a wonderful fiction based on the sketchy history of the Gnostic Gospels.
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A mesmerizing, thought-provoking read, Aug 14 2006
By N. Newnham - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Resurrection (Hardcover)
I loved this book, not only for what I learned, but for how it made me want to know more. It is an amazing and redemptive story -- and worth reading for the writing and the love story alone.
It was almost eery, after reading this novel which explores the complex and capricious way that history is written, to read David Marshall's review attacking Malarkey's facts. The fact is, these "facts" are largely a matter of opinion. There are many Christian schools and many Christian scholars with many points of view. I've read enough of them to know there is no definitive story. Faith is personal and Mr. Marshall, with his protests, shows this clearly enough. How can he simply dismiss Elaine Pagels as "one of the greatest sources of disinformation about early Christianity on the planet?" Like Bishop Iranaeus, he really does protest too much.
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Review by Malcolm McAfee (via another acct. S. Allen), Aug 16 2006
By S. Allen "Sodelle" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Resurrection (Hardcover)
Review of Tucker Malarkey's Resurrection
Malarkey does three things well:
1) She makes clear that the task of each of us is to create the meaning of our lives.
2) She illustrates with the proposition that recent new gospels modify our view of the Christian faith experience.
3) She does this in a convergence of three traditions:
a) The Anglican writers C.S.Lewis, Dorothy Sayers, Tolkien and Charles Williams.
b) The recent genre represented by Dan Brown's DaVinci Code.
c) Factual writers like John McPhee who bring us into Place and Person so convincingly that we cannot distinguish fact and fiction, nor does it matter.
We need Tucker Malarkey's book at the moment to take us on the journey of better experiencing each other and cherishing each other more.