5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Beatles' true masterpiece, Jun 1 2005
This review is from: Revolver (Audio CD)
1966 was The Beatles' greatest year. True, this year they ended touring, almost got killed in the Phillippines, and were denounced in America with record-burnings after Lennon said, "We're bigger than Jesus." Yet, out of this chaos rose The Beatles masterpiece, REVOLVER.
REVOLVER was considered Just Another Beatles Record when it was released in August 1966 and to some was considered their swan song in the dying days of Beatlemania. However, REVOLVER has stood the test of time and today outshines SGT. PEPPER. The reason is that the 1987 CD release ignored the inferior 11-track U.S. version of REVOVLER (omitting John's I'm Only Sleeping, And Your Bird Can Sing, Dr. Robert) and belatedly presented to North Americans the complete British 14-song album.
REVOLVER represents The Beatles at the top of their game. The level of composition is at its highest, outshining PEPPER and everything that followed. There is not a weak song here, lyrically or musically. The instrumentation by all four Beatles reaches its peak. Ringo, especially, earns top marks songs like She Said She Said and Tomorrow Never Knows. Lastly, the level of experimentation and breath of style is staggering. There are so many styles of music on REVOLVER, from classical to Indian raga to ballad to hard rock to soul and sampling (then called "tape loops") that the album almost bursts at the seams. Above all, this is a group effort which is lacking in later records such as the The White Album.
George takes a quantum leap forward on REVOLVER. He kicks off an album for the first time with Taxman, which features some of the sharpest lyrics ever to appear in a Beatles' song. Taxman signals that this is no Beatles album like any other. The lyrics are not cute, but bitter and biting, backed by one of Paul's best-ever bass lines (copped by Beck in The New Pollution). George's anger is also heard in the Raga-ish Love You Too, a rocking song that left many fans puzzled in 1966, but which has aged better than Within You Without You. His I Want To Tell You is a fine contribution to side two.
Paul displays his melodic, gentle side with two of his finest love songs, Here There and Everywhere and For No One, which feature exquisite vocals in the former, and a sparse but mournful arrangement in the latter. Unlike Michelle, Paul here avoids sentimentality and achieves beauty. Got To Get You Into My Life is a driving number featuring towering horns a la Stax, and actually describes an early pot experience (not acid as widely believed). Yellow Submarine (sung by Ringo) is a fun children's song, and Good Day Sunshine is also lighthearted and catchy without being shallow.
Most of all Eleanor Rigby stands as Paul's masterpiece, more mature in lyric and arrangement than Yesterday and not melodramatic and overproduced like the later She's Leaving Home. Rigby remains one of the Beatles' best lyrics and perhaps their most haunting tune. It never ages.
John too reaches a peak with REVOLVER. I'm Only Sleeping is an introspective song featuring backward guitars and confessional lyrics. She Said She Said recounts an acid trip in L.A. with Peter Fonda, and features some of Lennon's most harrowing imagery and stunning guitars-and-drums. And Your Bird Can Sing and Dr. Robert are fine rock songs.
Tomorrow Never Knows is the stunning conclusion to the album, full of tape loops, Ringo's hypnotic drumming and otherworldly lyrics inspired by the Tibetan Book of the Dead. Nothing ever sounded like this before and arguably not since.
REVOLVER is the culmination of four talents peaking at the same time. Others will insist on PEPPER as the definitive Beatles statement, but PEPPER has weaker songs, is self-consciously psychedelic, and is lopsided, favouring McCartney. REVOLVER sounds as fresh today as in 1966, and stands at the pinnacle of the Beatles' recording career. This is my favourite Beatles album and I never tire of playing it. Few albums by any band continue to sound fresh.
All Beatles albums have their qualities, but if there is one Beatles record you must pick up, this is the one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
I just love it, July 1 2004
This review is from: Revolver (Audio CD)
Honestly, I love this album. For me it's everything you want in a Beatles album. It's not just way out psychedelia, it's also got some quite catchy 60's pop too. It's sort of Please Please me meets Sgt Pepper. It's my favourite so far. But why is it so good? The individuality. Paul was getting more unique by making really tuneful old-fashioned sounding songs full with orchestration, beautiful harmonies and wonderful melodies. My favourite of his tracks is the wonderful Elanor Rigby. John Lennon is getting really weird and whacky and his fun but unusual rockers are great. So his individualism was shining through. My favourite track from him is Tomorrow never knows, really psychedelic. Then comes George's three contributions. He was probably [though I don't know for sure] frustrated at having to play 2nd fiddle and he wanted to be known as just as experimental and yet tuneful. So we have a tuneful 60's pop-rocker in Taxman, which is really social, Love you to, which has a really unusual melody and arrangement, and I want to tell you, my favourite song here, with a really unusual yet catchy melody. And of-course, Yellow Submarine is a gem, sung by Ringo. All in all a fabulous offering from the fab four.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Distinct Personalities, Jun 30 2004
This review is from: Revolver (Audio CD)
This album was released in Britian before the Beatles last American concert at Candlestick Park. The British version here includes material from the American only release of "Yesterday and Today". Even without the extra tracks it shows that the Beatles while still working as a group are showing some flowering into thier own sounds. Paul is more hit oriented with songs like "Eleanor Rigby", "Here There and Everywhere" John is more edgier with songs like "She Said She Said", and "Tomorrow Never Knows", George is getting into the act with "Taxman" as a slam that John wishes he would've wrote, and the love song "I Want To Tell You" that Paul could've written, but "Love You To" is George's alone as he showcases his sitar playing on this rather well, and Ringo just wants to have fun, and "Yellow Submarine" is given to him. Even with the personalities starting to flex thier muscles they still show group harmony with the song "Good Day Sunshine". Revolver has had some interesting raps taken at it as "The Acid Album" as the group was experimenting more and more with LSD, and also one of the numerous signs that "Paul Is Dead". With the album cover showing John, Ringo, and George facing front Paul is given a side shot like he doesn't fit in. However, it's still a worthy album, and it's my all time favorite.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No