Most helpful customer reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, Dec 13 2007
Gail Giles is the queen of psychological thrillers for teens. And I know that with her last release, I stated that WHAT HAPPENED TO CASS MCBRIDE? was my new favorite Giles book. However, I've taken the liberty of changing my mind (yes, again!) and saying that RIGHT BEHIND YOU tops even that great read. Kip McFarland lived in Alaska with his dad. His mother had gotten sick and died. His Aunt Jemma, his mother's sister, tried to insist that Kip's dad stop living like an animal in the wilds of Alaska, and instead move somewhere proper to raise her nephew. And then he did, because nine-year-old Kip killed Bobby Clarke by setting him on fire. In Indiana, he was Wade Madison, and he lived with his father and stepmother, Carrie. He became best friends with Dave, a teacher's son. He had a pretty hot girlfriend, Lindsey (also known as AC, for Absolutely Cutest). He was the star of the swim team. And then he couldn't take his own happiness anymore, went slightly ballistic with a group of his friends, and admitted to murdering a child. It was time to leave Indiana. Carrie's own stepfather had died, leaving her a house in Texas. In Texas, he was still Wade, but he wasn't the Wade from Indiana. And then he met Sam, a girl with tragic secrets of her own, and life changed yet again. He didn't want to be Wade, he wanted to be Kip. But not the Kip that the newspapers had made out to be a monster, and not even the Kip who had once been Wade who was friendly and outgoing and happy-go-lucky. All he wanted was a life that allowed him to accept what he had done without dying from the guilt. Get a copy of RIGHT BEHIND YOU. Read it and cry, and read it and think. Kip isn't a monster, but neither is he innocent. Kip is a boy who made a costly mistake, and has been paying for it ever since. This is his story, and it's an unforgettable one. Reviewed by: Jennifer Wardrip, aka "The Genius"
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Readergirl Reviews a Teen Book, Jan 12 2011
By Readergirl Reviews a Teen Book - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Right Behind You (Paperback)
Let me start out by saying that I was prepared to hate this book. I have very strongly held opinions on certain things, and one of them is that it's completely unforgiveable for someone to murder a child, even if the perpetrator was a child himself. I often cling to my beliefs and stubbornly refuse to be swayed, even, I'm ashamed to admit, when someone can logic me out of them. This book shook my beliefs. I found myself becoming so sympathetic to Kip/Wade, even if I didn't want to. There were extenuating circumstances, of course, that made Kip's act slightly different than one that might be committed by a truly sociopathic kid in training. Kip was intending to destroy something when he did it, and the fact that the victim caught fire was not intended. Does that make the act any easier to forgive or forget? No. Does it make it more excusable? No. Does it make it all right? No. But it does make the resulting journey to redemption more believable and desired. Kip/Wade spends his years after emerging from juvenile, moving around with his family. Just because the doctor's say he's rehabilitated, the angry public do not agree. He takes on a new name, a new home, and must begin his life again battling the guilt and shame of what he did. If his journey were portrayed as anything less than grueling and remorseful, it wouldn't have been as easy to forgive him and begin to root for him. The author handles this progression through Kip's many stages of growth so thoroughly and well, that by the time the end comes, I was fully in Kip's corner. Kudos to Ms. Giles for tackling such a difficult topic. A short Q&A is at the back of the book, in which she stated that she had received so much hate mail, mainly from outraged adults, regarding this book. The fact that she had the courage to tell such a controversial story in the face of such disapproval is great, because I would not have wanted to miss this book.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great for Adults, too!, Dec 20 2009
By Lynn ODell "Red Adept Reviews - A Blog" - Published on Amazon.com
Plot/Storyline: 5 Stars This novel achieved something rare, in my experience. It managed to be a Young Adult novel that had great appeal to adults. I didn't want to put the book down, so I read it in one day. The story is told in a diary-like manner with Kip (who later becomes Wade) as the narrator. As a mother myself, at first it was hard to sympathize with Kip because I kept thinking of the child he killed. Fortunately, the author doesn't require any sympathy or empathy for Kip in the beginning. Kip relates what happened in a very objective manner, just getting the facts out there. Kip himself doesn't ask for sympathy. As the story progresses, the reader becomes more emotionally invested in Kip/Wade's story. While I never quite got that other poor child, or his parents, out of my mind, I could still feel for Kip/Wade and for his parents. This is a fairly fast-paced novel that doesn't try to linger on a lot of thoughts or do any preaching. Kip/Wade's feelings come through loud and clear without him constantly harping on them to the reader. The ending was satisfying without being filled with saccharine. I found the entire book to be heartbreakingly realistic. Character Development: 4 1/2 Stars Kip/Wade was a well-developed, realistic, empathetic character in almost every aspect. The only downfall was that I found it hard to believe that growing up with the other institutionalized kids didn't affect him more. I would have thought that he would have been a little `harder' after those years. Kip/Wade's family and friends were sufficiently developed within the storyline. Writing Style: 5 Stars Giles does an excellent job of getting the reader inside the mind of a young boy as he is growing up. The dialogue, while somewhat watered down to stay within the YA genre, was still fairly realistic. The descriptions were minimal, befitting the diary-style of a young boy. The sentence structure was terrific and made for a well-flowing book. Editing/Formatting: 5 Stars Both were of professional quality. Rating: PG-13 for Sexual References and Adult Situations
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, Dec 13 2007
By TeensReadToo "Eat. Drink. Read. Be Merrier." - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Right Behind You (Hardcover)
Gail Giles is the queen of psychological thrillers for teens. And I know that with her last release, I stated that What Happened to Cass McBride? was my new favorite Giles book. However, I've taken the liberty of changing my mind (yes, again!) and saying that RIGHT BEHIND YOU tops even that great read. Kip McFarland lived in Alaska with his dad. His mother had gotten sick and died. His Aunt Jemma, his mother's sister, tried to insist that Kip's dad stop living like an animal in the wilds of Alaska, and instead move somewhere proper to raise her nephew. And then he did, because nine-year-old Kip killed Bobby Clarke by setting him on fire. In Indiana, he was Wade Madison, and he lived with his father and stepmother, Carrie. He became best friends with Dave, a teacher's son. He had a pretty hot girlfriend, Lindsey (also known as AC, for Absolutely Cutest). He was the star of the swim team. And then he couldn't take his own happiness anymore, went slightly ballistic with a group of his friends, and admitted to murdering a child. It was time to leave Indiana. Carrie's own stepfather had died, leaving her a house in Texas. In Texas, he was still Wade, but he wasn't the Wade from Indiana. And then he met Sam, a girl with tragic secrets of her own, and life changed yet again. He didn't want to be Wade, he wanted to be Kip. But not the Kip that the newspapers had made out to be a monster, and not even the Kip who had once been Wade who was friendly and outgoing and happy-go-lucky. All he wanted was a life that allowed him to accept what he had done without dying from the guilt. Get a copy of RIGHT BEHIND YOU. Read it and cry, and read it and think. Kip isn't a monster, but neither is he innocent. Kip is a boy who made a costly mistake, and has been paying for it ever since. This is his story, and it's an unforgettable one. Reviewed by: Jennifer Wardrip, aka "The Genius"
|
|
|