7 of 9 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Pretty good selection that showcases the various phases of "Roseanne" through the years, Sep 21 2011
By Larry Hirsch - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Roseanne - 10 Fan Favorite Episodes (DVD)
I agree with the selection of most of these episodes, such as:
Life and Stuff (Season 1) --- The pilot episode, which is probably the most realistic and honest portrayal of blue collar family life ever presented on TV. It's so realistic is almost borders on boring --- almost. Grade: A
Happy Birthday --- (Season 2) A touching and heartfelt episode without being sappy, honest and realistic. As a writer myself, this episode has always moved me. Grade: A+
Like a Virgin --- (Season 3) Darlene is caught making out with a boy (this was years before she met David Healy). A great episode, yes, but I wouldn't have included it for this collection. Grade: A
Confessions --- (Season 3) An excellent episode with fantastic and sharp writing, and one that we can all relate to. Grade: A+
Scenes From a Barbecue --- (Season 3) One of my personal favorites, this episode showcases the Conners relaxing and actually having fun before the turmoil and tense drama of later seasons. Grade: A+
Crime and Punishment --- (Season 5) Speaking of turmoil and drama, this episode is a MASTERPIECE, with virtuoso acting from Laurie Metcalf. Very, very touching. It's a dark episode, raw and uncomfortable, but also quite moving and pretty funny in parts. Grade: A+
War and Peace --- (Season 5) Part 2 of "Crime and Punishment," just as fantastic as its predecessor. Just phenomenol. Grade: A+
Wait Til Your father Comes Home --- (Season 5) Another dramatic episode, very raw and realistic, concerning the death of Roseanne's abusive, cheating father and her unique reaction to it. A classic episode. Grade: A+
A Stash From the Past --- (Season 6) One of the more controversial episodes, this one features what is perhaps the single funniest scene in the entire 9 year run of the show. Absolutely hysterical. A "drug episode" that is not preachy or sappy like in most sitcoms. Remember those "Very Special Episodes" from sitcoms in the 80's? This isn't one of them, that's for sure. Grade: A+
Sleeper --- (Season 7) A funny episode, but not worthy of inclusion in this collection. Still, it's quite enjoyable and amusing. Grade: B
It's pretty cheap and WELL worth the price, but do we really need 3 episodes from season 3? What about season 4, (highly regarded amongst "Roseanne" snobs such as myself as the show's best season)?
If left up to me, I would've chosen the following episodes:
_____________________________________________________________
Life and Stuff (Season 1) The pilot.
Toto, We're Not in Kansas Anymore (Season 1) The tornado episode.
Brain-Dead Poets Society (Season 2) Darlene discovers that she has a real talent for writing. BEAUTIFUL and moving.
Happy Birthday (Season 2) Roseanne tries to re-discover her talent for writing.
Confessions From a Barbecue (Season 3) The Conners celebrate Mother's Day and have a ton of fun. This episode introduces Nana Mary, one of the show's funniest characters.
Santa Claus (Season 4) Roseanne gets a job at the mall as Santa. Hilarious and the ending is very touching.
Wait Til Your Father Comes Home --- Roseanne's and Jackie's abusive and cheating father dies.
A Stash From the Past (Season 6) --- The infamous "pot episode."
Girl Talk (Season 7) Extremely coarse and vulgar, but insightful episode dealing with sex.
The Fifties Show (Season 8) An absolutely hysterical, clever, and witty spoof of 1950's sitcoms --- the complete opposite of what "Roseanne" is really about.
Just my 2 cents. :)
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Roseanne never disappoints, Nov 23 2011
By Harriet E. Kelly "grandmother of 7" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Roseanne - 10 Fan Favorite Episodes (DVD)
I don't know if these are MY favorites but in any case, Roseanne is always great. You can see the progression of her acting chops as she goes from her stand-up type delivery to a really good actor.
This is one of the smartest, best-written series that has ever been on TV. I have to admit, I never watched it when it was on originally and only discovered it on TV Land. Thank you TV Land! and thank you, Roseanne. You have gotten me through many a sleepless night with a smile.