Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, Aug 26 2007
In an age when questions of illegal immigration and exploitation of workers increasingly threaten to divide American society, M. E. Kerr presents a story of young interracial love that could be found anywhere in the country, not just in the resort town of Seaview, NY. All of the characters are here: the overt racist, protected by a successful position in the community; the young intellectual trapped between what he knows and who he loves; the businessman using illegal immigrants to his advantage, while convincing himself that he is doing them a favor; the immigrants themselves, some legal, some not, trying to build a life within a new culture, but also trying to retain their own heritage; and the young lovers, one hoping to improve himself, but constrained by the fact that he is in the U.S. illegally, and one too naïve to understand that love simply cannot conquer all. Yes, they are all here--and Kerr doesn't shy away from the ups or the downs. Kerr specifically showcases the complexities of prejudice in the character of Annabel's father, Kenneth Brown. Although he constantly belittles the Hispanic population, referring to people as "muchachos" and refusing to learn the names of his workers, simply referring to everyone as "Pedro" or "Jose," he seems to truly believe he is open-minded and forward thinking, simply because he is willing to hire Hispanic workers. The fact that he pays them less than half what he would pay an American worker doesn't register as racist whatsoever: "It's a darn good deal for them .... Most of them don't speak English, and some don't even have papers. I don't ask questions. I give them steady work. They learn on the job some of them, and they can earn as high as three hundred a week" (p. 12). Annabel, meanwhile, even though she is in love with a man from Colombia, remains in denial about her father's racism, defending him directly to Esteban: "My father sometimes uses that language ... but he doesn't mean to offend anyone. He's just from the old school. They don't know how offensive it is" (p. 165). Kenneth Brown knows better; Annabel Brown knows better; we all know better. And, as Kerr points out, we are all capable of racism and denial, regardless of our race. Esteban frequently makes excuses for his sister, who hates Annabel and calls her names solely because Annabel is ehite: "Stop throwing yourself at my brother, Flour Face" (p. 7). When it comes to prejudice and hatred, it seems, unfortunately, that there is enough to go around for everyone. In addition to putting a spotlight on the many problems we must face regarding immigration, Kerr does an excellent job of introducing the names of many giants of literature--Hemingway, e.e. cummings, Poe--and other artistic greats into the storyline. Kerr drops tidbits of information into the dialogue, providing just enough trivia to whet one's interest in these various artists, thus encouraging readers to hit the library and look for details beyond the SOMEONE LIKE SUMMER sound bite. Ultimately, this is an important work for so many reasons, and one must be somewhat courageous to even pick up the book and read it. Why? Because it's not a matter of if you will see yourself in the pages. Rather, the question is, "In which character will you see yourself?" Reviewed by: Mechele R. Dillard
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
How Does She Do It?, July 3 2007
By Peter - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Someone Like Summer (Hardcover)
Throughout her legendary career, M.E. Kerr has demonstrated an uncanny knack for writing exactly the right book at exactly the right time. GENTLEHANDS made the atrocities of the Holocaust vivid for late twentieth-century American kids. NIGHT KITES was the very first novel from a mainstream publisher to feature a gay man with AIDS. LINGER provided a stunning (and rare) fictional depiction of the first Iraq war. Now we have SOMEONE LIKE SUMMER, a romance between a Long Island girl and an illegal immigrant from Colombia. Considering how long it can take to write a book, not to mention the lengthy publication process that follows, how amazing that this book is being published at exactly the right time -- as our country is embroiled in a controversial battle over immigration. Ms. Kerr has done it again! The book is timely and topical but -- even better than that -- it's a great love story. The romance between its multifaceted protagonists, Annabelle and Esteban, is emotionally-involving and heartbreaking, as both teens battle family and community resistance to their relationship. The dialogue is fast-paced and often humorous. This book reads like a dream. Buy a copy of SOMEONE LIKE SUMMER and throw it in your beach bag; it's the perfect "beach book" for Summer 2007. When the season's over, shake the sand from its pages, and place it on your bookshelf. Sometime in the dark days of winter, you'll want to read it again -- and you'll be instantly transported to a time of barefoot walks on the shore, foggy afternoons in the sand dunes, and warm romantic nights, as you experience this perfect summertime romance again.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, Sep 12 2008
By Charlotte Blasier - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Someone Like Summer (Hardcover)
As a fan of ME Kerr and a librarian, I was quite excited to see this book arrive at our YA department. As soon as I saw the author's name I knew it was a must read. Unfortunately, I got 90 pages into the book and had to stop reading. The characterization was completely undeveloped and the dialogue was painful. I felt like the dialogue between the two main characters sounded like an episode of California Dreamin' or another one of those horribly acted Saturday morning teen shows from the 90s. I could understand Esteban spoke poorly since English was not his first language. But Annabel, her English was nearly as bad. Some of her sentences made no sense or were just very awkwardly worded. The plot development was poor as well. In young adult writing every word is important to the structure and tone of the story..not so in this story. I think ME Kerr is a wonderful author and I love the connection with libraries she has, but this book was just a complete mess in my opinion. I have never written a bad review before and I dont want to hurt anyone's feelings. I was just so surprised this book came from such a talented YA author.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Little Random, July 24 2008
By G. K. RN "optimism always." - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Someone Like Summer (Hardcover)
This book was pretty good. It was fast-paced and held your interest, and the romance was cutesy and nice. But it seemed a little bit random to me. There was something sort of off about Esteban--I couldn't put my finger on it, but he was strange. Also, his romance with Annabel--where did it come from? It basically started out of the blue. They looked at each other. And in their first-ever conversation, it was just..odd. Then out of nowhere, BAM, they're head-over-heels for each other. The lack of a build-up to this was very disappointing. People complain about the lack of build-up in Stephenie Meyer's "Twilight," between Edward and Bella. But that couple had much more basis than Esteban and Annabel. Then other things just didn't seem to fit. Such as Virgil and Mitzi's break-up, and Virgil wanting Mitzi to be tested for AIDS. Did we ever find out anything from there? No. Also, when Esteban wrote the song--about someone like summer. Nothing else ever came from it. Just..random. All in all, it was a good read, but it doesn't leave you thinking, wow, that was the greatest book ever. No, it actually leaves you wanting a better, more fulfilling book, if you ask me.
|
|
|