Ok. I was like you, I read all the feedback from previous buyers and did not have a clear consensus. I went ahead an purchased this item anyways.
-Looks like the picture
-Comes with front and rear protectors
-Rear protectors went on with no issues
-Case is easy to Install
-Front protector edges don't like to go flat and easily bubbles (Ill have to find a new one)
-The sides of the bumper case pull away from phone side easily with your hand. Could be an issue when pulling in and out of pockets.
-Its harder to access the sound/vibrate switch above volume buttons
Overall, the case is good. The only issue I really have is front screen protector and maybe the fitting of the case.