1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting for gay-fantasy fans, Dec 22 2003
Is it so much to ask that a book have deep, lush writing, strong characters, an interesting plot and real life scenes? While Swordspoint delivers on some of those points, it falls quite flat on others.
Of course, the plot is excellently crafted and fascinating, as other reviewers have mentioned. Kushner's semi-fantasy, semi-historical novel seems so very like our own, if history had taken different turns, and different values were held in higher esteem. Her world-building and plot-twisting cannot be faulted, however, her relationship-expounding certainly can.
Each of the characters that we read the most about (Richard, Alec and Michael) are strong fellows with a true depth of character, even when that character is mysterious and shrouded (as in the case of Alec). Each feels ultimately real, with passions, hatreds, needs, desires, strengths and flaws. It's only when the characters interact with one another that my interest started to wane. Initially, I found Richard and Alec's relationship hauntingly fascinating, but something was lacking. I never truly felt their closeness, even when Richard takes great pains and goes to great lengths for Alec's honor and safety. Some measure of connection was glossed over, and truly.
Now, I gave this book four stars as it is, The problem was that each time I felt I was about to see some depth to the characters' relationships -- whether between Michael and the Duchess, or Richard and Alec, or anyone involved (and many of them are!) -- the author took a step back and veiled her readers' eyes from the emotional as well as the physical details. Tender, delicate wording did not serve to spare my sensibilities. It only served to turn my reader's eyes away from the most intimate moments of the characters' relationship: emotional as well as physical.
However, the book itself is a wonderful read, and interesting enough for me to want The Fall of the Kings to see if Kushner can top Swordspoint, and possibly show me a little more intimacy. In all senses of the word.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
nice bookcover, May 15 2010
I bought this book based on the cover (which I find very beautiful)
The plot is ok, some political stuff behind it.
But I was disappointed that the love life between Alec and Richard was not fully portrayed. The knight keeps going off fighting while the other is just... there. not very present.
It might be interesting for those who enjoy stories about knights and duels though I was really hoping for the love between Alec and Richard to go on to a next level throughout the story. slightly disappointed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lovely language and description, Feb 2 2010
This book exploded all the tropes. It was a fantasy without magic, a tragedy where the two main characters live, and a love story without romance. Or, at least the sort of 'romance' you see with half-naked men on the covers. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No