From School Library Journal
Grade 3-5-A handsome, readable book that combines general information with the personal record of the trip made by Sobol and his son to the birthing grounds of the harp seal on a pack of ice in the Gulf of the St. Lawrence. Lavishly illustrated with crisp full-color photos, Seal Journey gives insight into the life cycle of the harp seal, the history of efforts to curtail the brutal clubbings of the snowy pups for their shimmering coats (for this herd at least), and the feelings of a young boy who watches pups being born, nursing, and learning to swim. Report writers may cling to Olga Cossi's more detailed Harp Seals (Carolrhoda, 1991), but readers will enjoy accompanying Jonah and his father in the chill bitter cold of an early Arctic spring. A page of seal facts will aid researchers.
Patricia Manning, Eastchester Public Library, NYCopyright 1993 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
Gr. 6-8. Black-eyed, white-furred seal pups are among the most appealing of animals, and Sobol's pictures, taken on a breeding island in the Gulf of St. Lawrence, make the most of their photogenic quality. He shows a pup so newborn that its coat is still matted and stained from the birth canal. He shows the same pup nursing, older pups learning to swim or wriggle their way over the snow, and the whole colony spread across the snow, looking like chocolate sprinkles scattered on top of a huge bowl of vanilla ice cream. His text relates the long struggle to prohibit the clubbing of these newborns and to protect the breeding grounds. Sobol took his eight-year-old son Jonah with him, and his photographs of Jonah petting and holding one of the pups should arouse both interest and envy among young readers. A well-written text with excellent photographs.
Sheilamae O'Hara