From School Library Journal
Grade 7-10-Buffie picks up the action shortly after the conclusion of The Watcher (Kids Can, 2000). Emma, raised as human, now knows herself to be an alien Watcher, sent to Earth to protect her changeling sister, Summer, now the queen of Argadnel. The protagonist finds herself involved in the interplanetary gaming between Fergus of Cleave and his rivals, playing a magical board game to earn her freedom, and the chance to search for her mother's true daughter, Ailla, whose presence may restore her mother's health. With her friend Tom, a Watcher who has been transformed into a bird by Fergus, and a series of allies and enemies, Emma travels through alien worlds in a real-life game where Ailla is the prize. Emma is a headstrong, appealing narrator, and Buffie uses her first-person perspective to smoothly provide background for readers unfamiliar with the first volume. The characters have depth and complex motivations, keeping the protagonist and readers guessing about who her true friends may be. While the initial slow pacing may be daunting, this is a good choice for sophisticated fantasy readers, with a strong appeal for gaming fans looking for a darker, more complex story than Diana Wynne Jones's The Homeward Bounders (Greenwillow, 2002).
Beth L. Meister, Yeshiva of Central Queens, Flushing, NYCopyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
Gr. 5-8. In this sequel to
The Watcher (2000), Emma has been transported to Argadnel, an island kingdom where her changeling sister, Summer, is now the queen. Their mother, who is grieving for her missing husband and real child, lies near death, so Emma determines to rescue her lost sister and arrange for their father's return. Her quest is complicated by various fantastic creatures, which may be allies of Fergus and Rhona, who are involved in an intricate power game. An appended glossary of characters and place names will help readers keep track of the enormous cast, and early chapters explain the events from the first novel in the Watcher's Quest trilogy. Buffie's ability to keep the story moving without a lag in the action also helps this book to stand on its own. A welcome choice for fantasy buffs.
Kay WeismanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved