Howes victory allowed him to capture Philadelphia, but he failed to destroy Washingtons army and failed to rally the residents, including a large Quaker community, to the British cause.
| |||||||||||||||
Howes victory allowed him to capture Philadelphia, but he failed to destroy Washingtons army and failed to rally the residents, including a large Quaker community, to the British cause.
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
Mowday not only includes repetitive quotes but also often repeats himself. As an example, every time Captain John Marshall is mentioned, Mowday reminds the reader that Marshall would some day sit on the Supreme Court. An important point but the author's first notation of this point was sufficient. Between his own repetitions and the extremely long quoted passages, one gets the idea the author is simply trying to make the book long enough to be worth printing.
The sad thing is that when Mowday actually takes the time to write for himself the text is fairly smooth and enjoyable. Just as one is beginning to enjoy the book however, along comes another long quoted passage. Quite frankly, the author is correct in saying this battle does not get the attention it deserves but unfortunately he does the subject no justice. The troop movements, which are the key to understanding the battle, are hard to follow and what maps there are leave much to be desired. It is just simply hard to figure out what is going on. Add to these problems a severe lack of depth as the author never more than scratches the surface. For example, General Howe's decision to abandon Johnny Burgoyne and head for Philadelphia is barely covered. Probably the most important aspect of the Philadelphia campaign is that Burgoyne, left on his own, was forced to surrender his army which probably helped bring France into the war. Mowday never mentions Howe's intense dislike for Burgoyne and his probable desire to see Gentleman Johnny fail. Howe would have had to completely destroy Washington at Brandywine to make up for what happened to Burgoyne, but Mowday never mentions this scenario.
Mowday obviously knows his subject and has done a considerable amount of research. His writing is excellent when he actually writes something and I kept thinking the book would get better. Unfortunately it didn't. I realize that for the author, this was a labor of love and I would really like to recommend this book, but I can't.