Quill & Quire
Contemporary cultural criticism and immersive journalism often take the form of a road trip, albeit to places a little off the tourist track. In
The Sheikh’s Batmobile, author Richard Poplak scores some heavy frequent-flier miles visiting a series of countries that fall under the vast umbrella of “the Muslim world.” The result is an entertaining travelogue that observes the significant impact American popular culture has had on foreign cultural scenes. Poplak’s itinerary is impressive. He goes bowling in Kazakhstan (and, incidentally, finds out what the kids really think of Borat); listens to metal in Cairo, punk in Indonesia, and hip-hop in Palestine; watches
The Simpsons in Dubai; plays video games in Syria; and even tries some bruising backyard wrestling in Afghanistan. The writing is colourful and punchy, giving plenty of scope for Poplak to display his talent for dramatic, on-the-spot reportage. He often has occasion, for example, to describe how loud music
feels: the bass that “nestled in my gut like a fat slug, writhing, looking for an exit of its own,” the concert hall that “heaved forward in a single movement, like a gag reflex before puking.” Where the book has limits is in describing the big picture. Given the range of activity Poplak investigates, as well as the evident diversity – economic, religious, political, geographic – of the Muslim countries he visits, this isn’t surprising. It’s hard to generalize from such a wide-ranging collection of data. Any connections between the chapters hang by very thin threads. One relative constant derives from the fact that pop culture is largely youth culture, and this is mainly the world Poplak explores. But even this tells us something about the places he visits, as most of them have young populations. And since Poplak is of the same general cohort, and a fan of much of what he hears and sees – though admitting to some feelings of ambivalence and occasional reservations over things like the link between metal music and terror – he relates well with all of the people he meets. Another guiding principle is Poplak’s abiding optimism. He sees American pop culture, despite being undeniably trashy most of the time, as playing a beneficent role, building a cultural wall against Islamic radicalism and fundamentalism while forging relationships with the wider world. He only briefly mentions critiques of the American entertainment-industrial complex and concerns over global cultural homogenization, and has little time for those who believe that the agenda behind American “soft power” is political as well as commercial. Though some promising opportunities for criticism are passed by, overall this is an excellent informal tour of a complex and rapidly evolving cultural terrain.
Review
"A heroic feat of research, analysis, and on-the-ground reportage. ... It's a weird, wonderful world where ... pop is revered and high and low culture freely mingle. ... The Sheikh's Batmobile should shatter the Western stereotype of the Muslim world as repressive and stagnant."
--Jason McBride,
Quill & Quire
