If you want an introduction to the world of Sherlock Holmes and his admirers, this is the book for you. The author is an authority on all things "Sherlockian" and spares no secrets. Overall his approach is balanced. There is a wealth of information here. Do not expect to race through this book. You will find it on my bookshelf with my copy(s) of the Canon.
Was this review helpful to you?
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
That rarity -- a reference book that's delightfully readableDec 16 2010
R. B. Bernstein
- Published on Amazon.com
Christopher Redmond has created that true rarity -- a reference book that's delightfully readable. No matter if you have the usual standards, such as the late Jack Tracy's ENCYCLOPAEDIA SHERLOCKIANA, you should get a copy of this fine book for the Sherlockian in your life -- or for yourself, if you love Sherlock Holmes. I've read the stories countless times since I was a boy and I've also read a lot of the critical literature in the field, but this book not only presents the basics that you need to know to understand Sherlock Holmes, his world, his creator, and the cultural force and icon that he has become -- it does it with wit, flair, clarity, sound judgment, and an admirably independent perspective. Redmond is to be congratulated. I only hope that he keeps revising and updating this volume -- this is the second edition (2009) -- to take account of the continuing fascination with Sherlock Holmes and his world.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
Perhaps the Best Book on the Subject of Them AllFeb. 26 2013
Robert A. Byrne
- Published on Amazon.com
NOTE: This review is for the first edition
A must for any Sherlockian library" and similar phrases seem to appear a bit too often. The Canon can be enjoyed without 100 accompanying books next to it on your shelf. However, there are a few books that stand head and shoulders above the rest and really should be read to greatly increase your Holmes experience.
Christopher Redmond has written one of them. The Canadian, who maintains the internet's leading Sherlock Holmes website, Sherlockian.net, is a well-known Sherlockian and Baker Street Irregular. A Sherlock Holmes Handbook is thoroughly researched, covers a broad array of topics and, most importantly, is easy and enjoyable to read.
The first chapter is an overview of the Canon, mentioning when each tale was first published (individually or as a collection) and touching on a highlight or two per story. It is assumed that anyone who buys this book is already familiar with the Holmes adventures, so it is in chapter two that the real fun begins.
'Characters and Adventures' kicks off with a discussion of Holmes and his characteristics ("Holmes is moody, alternating periods of energy, enthusiasm and prodigious work with periods of languor, inactivity and apparent depression"). Of course, Watson is next, then the supporting characters, including Professor Moriarty, ("in short....the modern day Jonathan Wild"), Irene Adler, Mycroft Holmes and a few others. There is mention of the unpublished cases, 221B Baker Street, the great detective's methods and overtones in the stories (from the hero archetype to sexual motifs). I was a fan of this book by the end of chapter two.
Chapter three focuses on Sherlock Holmes in print and touches on sources for the tales and characters, original publication of the stories, copyrights and illustrations. This is a pretty interesting chapter for the layman in these areas.
If you haven't read an in-depth biography of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (several are reviewed in this site's Reference Works section), you can't go wrong with chapter four, which is about Doyle and includes a nice discourse on his military and spiritualist interests.
I am not an expert on Victorian England. I learned a great deal from chapter five, titled 'The Victorian Background'. Redmond talks about the rail system, London itself, public affairs, social classes, newspapers, telegraphs, European affairs and more. You really get a sense of how the times played a part in the Holmes tales. He finishes with a nice `Who's Who' of the era. My understanding of the backgrounds throughout the Holmes adventures was enhanced by what I learned here.
The next chapter discusses crime and punishment in Victorian England, along with a brief overview of detective fiction.
Chapter seven is a nice potpourri called 'Holmes in Modern Media.' Pastiches, parodies, films, television, theater, radio and other forums are covered. Of course, this is by no means a complete listing of these areas, but it is a wide ranging look that includes specifics such as a listing of the Rathbone films, a mention of the Solar Pons books and the musical, Baker Street. You'll find something of interest in this chapter.
'Fans and Followers' discusses Sherlockiana and the birth of Societies. Even the most knowledgeable Sherlockian and Holmesian will likely find some nugget of information here.
The final chapter touches on such topics as Holmes museums, memorials, statues, restaurants and the like. Redmond mentions Holmes in advertising and references from other literature. He finishes with a talk about the appeal of Sherlock Holmes. Isaac Asimov says "How wonderful to have intelligence made so plain and so straightforward that any reader can feel that he might be that intelligent, too, with a bit of luck." Well put!
There is an appendix with all of the tales from the Canon listed with their Christ abbreviations, and a thorough index.
If I could only pick one tome from my reasonably-sized Holmes library to accompany the Canon, it would be Christopher Redmond's A Sherlock Holmes Handbook. No other one volume adds so much to my enjoyment and experience of Doyle's sixty tales. I can think of no higher recommendation
0 of 4 people found the following review helpful
interesting but a bit boringAug. 21 2013
- Published on Amazon.com
Format: Kindle Edition
Interesting but a bit boring. Definitely too long. Detail extensive but too long. Could have been tol in less words