Most helpful customer reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
A flawed but perfect character study, Aug 23 2002
It took awhile to get through this one. While the plot was interesting enough to stimulate continued interest, there were so so many distractions along the way that it seemed I complained more about this novel than I did singing its praises (reviewer pauses while reader re-checks the number of stars.) I'll start with those distractions if you promise to stay with me to the end. These characters are horrid. I cringed with pain reading on the first few pages where Special Agent Starr displayed his habits of speaking with a fake Southern drawl and dispensing folklore from his old pappy. I feared I had a long road ahead as just a few pages later, Mr. Diamond, 'dried his crotch reflectively.' Other than Hel, the Japanese General whom he paternally bonds with, and the Go teacher, we are provided a long long cast of dim witted, big busted, sexually talented/enthusiastic drivel. Nearly all of the female characters are so abhorrently shallow they are basically incapable of doing anything other than stenography or achieving an orgasm. The consistently bungling portrayal of intelligence operatives, both CIA and British MI, are flagrant and inflammatory. Neither flavor shows the dedication, love of country, and intelligence that I know are near universal characteristics of those who dedicate their lives to defending their homelands. Instead we are shown callous, inept thugs, who build the murder of their own brothers in arms into their plans to cover their own tracks.
The nearly constant berating of America and all things American has turned the stomach of more than one red white and blue reader of the novel. It should be noted that this in not the only nationality beaten and bruised in the book, far from it. In certain contexts within the story this America bashing is well justified, especially those being told from the Nickolai Hel perspective. But it bleeds over into pretty much all of the book, and it is distracting from the brilliance that lies beneath it all. Oh yes, it is brilliant. The brilliance of this story is the character study of Nickolai Hel and his pursuit of Shibumi, a very Zen state of unpretentious perfection. Nickolai Hel endures, grows, and pursues. All along actively pursuing that state of perfection in himself. Unfortunately, I can't go much beyond that description without providing a most undeserved spoiler. All that I can say is read this novel with a critical eye. Do not let the hate and racism distract you from the deeper meaning. There is a lesson to be learned in this one, but it does not come for free.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Modern medieval anti-hero of the establishment., Oct 8 2003
When this novel was first published in 1979, the leading critics had a difficult time classifying the work. It wasn't exactly an espionage thriller or an epic, but it seemed to touch upon many genres and themes. ~Shibumi~ is a fictional biography more than anything else, for its central character, Nicholai Hel, is the tale's main concern. A minor character in the story sums up the protagonist superbly at the end of the book by calling him half saintly ascetic, half Vandal marauder - a medieval anti-hero. Nicholai Hel is your vintage 'man-against-the establishment' with a mind like a steel trap and the tastes and lifestyle of an 18th century aristocrat. His pedigree is a throw back to the German/Russian elite, where generations of breeding and culture have contributed to his unusual character. Nicholai is a man without a country, a natural mystic, philosopher, linguist, master of Go, a complex Japanese board game of high strategy, and most importantly, a self trained assassin for hire who is expert in the arts of naked/kill. More than this, he is a seeker of spiritual perfection, his ultimate goal being that hard to define state or condition known as Shibumi. Trevanian (Rodney Whitaker) is a first rate writer. His technical skill in the craft well exceeds many leading 'thriller' writers of today. When one reads about the art of naked/kill, the mystical states of Nicholai Hel, or even the machinations of the CIA and their unscrupulous methods for creating and combating terror, one gets the distinct impression that the author knows exactly what he's talking about and must have access to some kind of inside information. His writing is almost too believable. Throughout the reading, I had to continue to remind myself that this novel was written in 1979, well before the general public had any concern about terrorism. Other than the main character, this tale is about corruption in governments, who will go to any lengths to secure oil rights in the Middle East. The book is also about technology, which has aided civilization in many ways, yet has eroded our basic values. In many respects, Nicholai Hel is a modern Luddite, despising machines in all their forms, and the waste they create. Nicholai Hel is an 'everyman' character, a representation of the virtuous individual, alone and pitted against the dangerous technological and consumerist values of the herd. In the end, however, does Nicholai Hel win this battle over the modern, vulgar, techno-centred majority and finally attain 'Shibumi'? This work should be considered a classic, for it has a timelessness about it, and can be read many times, for it will continue to offer intellectual stimulation as well as pure entertainment for many years to come.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
Great Start, Then Crashes and Burns, Jan 30 2003
I couldn't put the book down, as they say, for its first half. Although I knew I was reading a Japanese view of WWII, it was nonetheless fascinating if terribly incomplete and as one sided as an American WWII propanganda film. Then when the book moves locales to the Basque region and modern times, it tumbles and falls deeply into coyness and predictability. All of a sudden, it's as if some ronin author barged in, drugged the first author and started writing some one dimensional cartoon novel. The characters become cardboard and cute and the protaganist's sermonizing puts him right up there with the Sunday T.V. preachers genre, albeit the protaganist is pushing a different theology. A good writer realizes there is no black and white in any character: within the circle there is the yin and the yang and even within each yin there is a little yang and vice versa. This makes for authenticity, for we see ourselves in the mixture.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|