Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful
The Real J'onn J'onzzDec 18 2008
- Published on Amazon.com
First the bad news - this is all printed in black & white - so be it. The wonderful news - you get all the J'onn J'onzz stories from the first one in 1955 through Detective Comics # 304 published in 1962. The final twenty or so stories finishing J'onn's run in Detective Comics are not included. This is the real J'onn J'onzz from the 1950s. It does not get better than this.
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
Historically interesting...July 3 2008
- Published on Amazon.com
The evolution of the Martian Manhunter is rather interesting to watch unfold. He starts out much different than you might be used to. The first half of these stories are basically private eye/detective type stories. Martian Manhunter operates invisibly without the general populace even knowing he exists. I find MM's vulnerability to fire to be annoying at best. Fire affects him the same way kryptonite affects Superman. Anytime someone lights a cigarrette in his presence he passes out. I wish they had just gone with the idea that he wasn't invulnerable to fire instead of it actually weakening him. MM would have benefited from a supporting cast (there isn't much of one) and some colorful villains to battle (none of those either).
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful
J'on J'onzz, The Martian Manhunter As He Originally WasMarch 20 2009
- Published on Amazon.com
I'm glad to see that DC Comics put out this second volume of "Showcase presents the Martian Manhunter" completing the series run as a back-up feature in "Detective Comics" (with Batman as the lead feature).
The "Martian Manhunter" series was then moved to "House of Mystery" comics that originally featured monster and sci-fi stories as a lead feature.
This was done when due to the poor and slumping sales of the Batman titles, Publisher Donanfeld reassigned the Batman titles from Editor Robert Canniger to Editor Julie Schwartz asking Schwartz to revamp the series and try to save it and do to it what he did with "The Flash" and "Green Lantern."
The Martian Manhunter" series, however, remained with Editor Robert Canniger who put it as lead feature in "House of Mystery" comics. A new series featuring "The Elongated Man" replaced "The Martian Manhunter" series in "Detective Comics."
J'on Jonzz, the Martian Manhunter, was also given a comical sidekick, an imp from the Fifth Dimension named Zook who was the color orange and had two antennae on this forehead. Another change made at this time was that the Martian Manhunter decides to stage the death of his alter ego, Police Detective John Jones. He needs to concentrate full time on this threat that is menacing the whole city. The Martian Manhunter and his partner Zook operated and lived is a hidden cave. They would enter the cave by walking through the caves walls.
The Martian Man hunter's comical sidekick, Zook, is later killed off.
"The Martian Manhunter" ran as the lead feature in "House of Mystery" for about two years and then was relegated to being a back-up feature again in "House of Mystery" with a new lead feature replacing it, "Dial H for Hero."
By the end of the 1960's, both superhero series were canceled, and the "House of Mystery" title was turned into a book dealing with stories of the occult and supernatural.
The Martian Manhunter who was also a member of "The Justice League of America" was also removed from the book as a member of the team.
Since 1955 when the Martian Manhunter first appeared in the pages of "Detective Comics," things had changed and much more about the planet Mars was known such as Mars has no life and cannot support human life on it. (Now we know that there does exist bacterial life on Mars, but no sentient life forms or civilizations).
By the late 1960's, the Martian Manhunter had become obsolete and irrelevant. Editor Julie Schwartz and writer Denny O'Neil decided to have the Martian Manhunter written out of the "Justice League of America."
J'on Jonzz, the Martian Manhunter, had repaired the scientist's teleported machine, which originally brought him to Earth years ago leaving him stranded on Earth. We now find that J'on Jonzz (the Martian Manhunter) was a political exile, exiled to the deserts of Mars by a dictator he spoke out against. That was when the Martian Manhunter had be caught in this scientist's teleported ray bringing him to Earth.
Back on Mars, the Martian Manhunter discovers that this ruthless dictator still in power plans to exert and strengthen his control over the people of Mars with the use of a weapon that goes beyond being a Weapon of Mass Destruction. This is a weapon that when set off can destroy the whole atmosphere of Mars leaving Mars a barren waste land with an atmosphere that can no longer support life.
The Martian Manhunter manages to teleport back to Earth and enlists the aid of his fellow Justice League members who go back to Mars with him. The ruthless dictator sets off the bomb in the end and Mars's atmosphere and civilization are laid waste. However, a rocket ship did manage to leave Mars containing a number of Martians did get away and went off to another planet in another solar system to colonize and star a new civilization. The Martian Manhunter decides to leave the Justice League to use a rocket ship left still functional to pursue and join the other Martians in the other world to help rebuild the Martian civilization.
These two volumes of "Showcase presents the Martian Manhunter are worth getting.
In a later "World's Finest Comics" issue done when Superman was the feature character in team-up stories, Superman goes to aid the Martian Manhuter on New Mars that orbits an orange sun. Under the rays of the orange sun, Superman only half their strength. This story is included in the first volume of compilation. Also included in the first volume is the first of the team-up series that ran in "The Brave and the Bold" comics. This was prior to Batman being cast as the featured character in the team-ups. The first team-up teams the Martian Manhunter with Green Arrow and Speedy.
As you know, teh Martian Manhunter was returned to the Justice League of America on Earth in the 1980's. They tried the Martian Manhunter in his own title later, but it was not successful.
I, myself, prefer the Martian Manhunter as he originally was in the 1960's, and these two volumes are a complete collection of the Martian Manhunter as he originally was.
These two volumes are good and fun reading.
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful
Only for die hard MM fansMarch 6 2008
- Published on Amazon.com
This is a collection for people who have a jones (no pun intended) for some campy, nostalgic, good-old MM action. I am one of those people. Definitely worth the money if you really like classic comics for their style of story telling. The first several issues are enjoyable simply because they are so ridiculous, but as the volume progresses, the art gets better, and the storytelling is more enjoyable in and of itself. Unfortunately it cuts off before the seventies start. That's okay, I would like to see more emphasis on new Manhunter Story TPB anyway.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
The Manhunter from MarsSept. 25 2013
Adam Graham, Superhero and Detective Fiction Author
- Published on Amazon.com
J'onn J'onzz, the Manhunter from Mars was a classic DC character and early Justice League member. He began his career in 1955 in a back up feature to Batman in Detective comics in a series of page features. That's why this book can easily contain the first 80 of his solo adventures.
The book begins with a story from Batman #78 called the Manhunter from Mars from 1953. The story and character don't appear to have anything to do with the Martian Manhunter, but hey Batman reprints from the 1950s are somewhat rare.
We then meet J'onn J'onzz in Detective Comics #225. He a Martian, brought to Earth through a scientist's experiment. The scientist dies as J'ohn is stranded and decides to fight crime on Earth while waiting for a way back to Mars. He assumes the identity of John Jones and becomes a police detective (about as easily as Superman became Clark Kent reporter in some early stories) and sets out on an incredible career of fighting crime.
During the Manhunter's early years, the Superhero genre was in decline, so the Martian Manhunter was much more of a super powered detective than a superhero. He had to solve the case as John Jones and present criminals for prosecution. Six page comic book stories were often very poorly written, but these unsigned stories were actually very well done, with clever mysteries and some nice plot twists. What made it fun too was that the Manhunter did most of his work invisible. While other heroes had a secret identity, his entire existence was a secret.
Of course, there was some repetition. I lost count of how many times we were told the Manhunter's weakness was fire, but other than that, the stories were great.
The rise of the Superhero genre led to a change in the series. After 4 years, a Martian criminal (despite the fact that we were told in the first story that crime didn't exist on Mars) came to Earth and shot J'onn with a ray that made it so he couldn't use his Martian powers when invisible, and in order to save the day, the Martian Manhunter revealed his existence to the world.
From there, the Martian Manhunter becomes a much more typical Silver Age superhero story. I know that many alternate stories imagine 1950s Earth being hostile to the Manhunter forcing him underground as part of the constant beefing against the 1950s, but the way the book acts in 1959, people just thought, "Oh, he's from Mars, cool."
While the latter tales we're not as good, they were probably better written than many others. The length forbid the stories from getting too silly or too off-track for the most part. Of course, they did get a little longer. The stories changed from 6 pages to 7 with Detective Comics #280 in June of 1960 and leapt to 12 pages with Detective Comics #301 in March 1962.
The last of the 12 page stories in the book seemed to present the most problems. It was about a crime college where criminal students tries to keep up their grades while using outlandishly silly crime devices to commit robberies. In this story, the chief of Police mentions the Manhunter's weakness to fire (his only weakness) when the Manhunter had tried and succeeded from keeping everyone from knowing about it. In the last story, the chief knows but criminals don't for some reason.
Still even that story was fun. Which is a good word for the whole book. Of eighty-one classic comic book stories, there were a few weak ones, but overall this is just a truly fun enjoyable book taking a look at an underrated Silver Age character.