1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Media Censorship around the world., Oct 15 2005
By John Matlock "Gunny" - Published on Amazon.com
Ce commentaire est de: Silenced International Journalists Expose Media Censorship (Hardcover)
The people writing the constitution of the United States were pretty bright people. They had come from a climate where fundamental freedoms were denied. So they put in a few amendments. The first, is on freedom of speech. And as the editor of this book says in his introductory chapter, four little words 'or of the press' made a lot of things happen that wouldn't have be possible otherwise -- Watergate for instance.
In this book he has selected, mostly, a series of articles on what happened to reporters who reported who reported something their governments didn't want published. These are mostly international where there is neither a tradition or a guarantee of freedom of the press. The reporters writing the articles say that they are mistreated by the governments for exposing governmental misconduct.
Yes, I expect that this is what happens. George Washington's remarks on government being an instrument of force, not of reason comes to mind. Governments from the UN to the local school board don't want all their actions brought to light. Where 'or of the press' isn't applicable this is what you have to expect.
In the articles from the United States there doesn't seem to be a lot of governmental influence, it's the reporters not writing what the owners want. That's the way capitalism works. If you want to print what the owner doesn't want, you are welcome to start your own news service (and the web has made this very cheap to do).
And after debating these issues where reports are exposing crime and corruption at risk to themselves, why is the headline in my local paper today about the teacher's union and the school board arguing about pay. Can't they find any scandals?
I find that I also want to ask if this editor, very anxious to defend the first amendment, will also defend the second on bearing arms.
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
SILENCED: International Journalists, Sep 20 2005
By Professor Alfredo Pastor - Published on Amazon.com
Ce commentaire est de: Silenced International Journalists Expose Media Censorship (Hardcover)
The topic is interesting, but most of the stories were very commonplace, involving disagreements between ownership and editorial policy. Compared with Into the Buzzsaw, a book dealing with the same topic, this one overemphasizes journalists' complaints; as such, the book obscures rather the big issue of freedom of the press.