Books in Canada
Glen Huser charmed me with Stitches, his book for readers eleven to thirteen years of age. Im not as taken with this book for young adults thirteen and older, although its clear Huser is a talented writer poised to write a novel for adults. There are passages in this novel of mature reflection on music and operatic plot, on relationships, and the painful reality of growing old. They are beautiful, touching, sad, but their overall affect is to present the young reader with a character and sensibility they may not easily relate to, especially when such a sensibility is juxtaposed with that of a much younger character.
Told in two alternating first-person narratives, this is the story of fifteen-year-old Tamara, a tall, thin teen with attitude and typical interest in fashion, and prickly ninety-year-old Miss Barclay, a nursing home resident to whom Tamara is assigned when her class begins to visit the home on a weekly basis. Miss Barclay mourns the loss of her independence and longs for the cultural excursions of her past. She is particularly fond of Wagner, and the thought of missing the upcoming performances of the whole Ring Cycle in Seattle fills her with despair. She smokes cigarettes and imbibes brandy on the sly, breaking nursing home rules. Meanwhile, foster child Tamara is also breaking rules by skipping school with forged sick notes. She uses the time away from classes to watch fashion television as well as to make a trip to an agency, where she learns about a summer modelling course being held in Vancouver. The course is expensive, but beyond that, theres no way any one-not her foster parents, the Shadbolts, and certainly not her social worker, Mr. Mussbacher-would let an underaged girl with a poor behavioural record make the trip alone.
Both Tamara and Miss Barclay are in the same bind, and both are desperate, desperate enough to turn to one another. Its the unlikeliest of duos, but working together they manage to convince the Shadbolts and the nursing home staff that Miss Barclay will be spending a couple of weeks at her house, arranging her belongings so that the house can be put up for sale, with Tamara as her hired companion. What theyre actually planning is a course of action that is outrageous, daring, and dangerous, but that will enable both to get what they want: for Miss Barclay, a chance to attend the Ring Cycle in Seattle, and for Tamara, the Vancouver modelling course, paid for by Miss Barclay in exchange for being driven from Edmonton to Seattle and being accompanied to the Opera.
The road trip, with a fifteen-year-old inexperienced driver at the wheel, and an ailing ninety-year-old in constant need of care, is a reckless undertaking-a quixotic trip that somehow echoes the thrilling elements in opera. At the end of the adventure, a furious police officer tells Miss Barclay that she was acting irresponsibly, and that only her frail condition prevents him from arresting her for endangering her own life and Tamaras. And Tamara, though fortunate to be brought back to Edmonton safe and sound, gets another sobering lesson about the consequences of breaking too many rules. In the end, though, this novel has a happy conclusion-one that is too tidy for me, but that will, I imagine, satisfy younger readers.
Olga Steinj/I> (Books in Canada)
From School Library Journal
Grade 7 Up—Tamara, a not-quite-15-year-old foster kid, describes with cynicism her deposit with yet another family. She's anorexic, she's a liar and truant, and she defines herself as a future model. Jean Barclay is a crotchety 89-year-old rest-home resident with a bum hip and a bourbon dependency. Brought together for a school project, each one realizes that the other has something she needs: Tamara can drive Jean to Seattle to see a series of beloved operas, and Jean can pay for a modeling course for Tamara in Vancouver. In alternating first-person narratives, they relate their plan to drive cross country-one to bring closure to a life, and the other to open a door. References to Dickens's
Great Expectations and Wagner's Ring Cycle frame the text with some success, but Huser's prose is clunky, and his pacing is labored. The narrative voices are neither distinct from one another nor convincing. Most disappointing is the characters' lack of depth and growth. Both have serious problems (alcoholism, eating disorders) that are oddly made light of. Martha Brooks's
True Confessions of a Heartless Girl (Farrar, 2003) and Patricia Reilly Giff's
Pictures of Hollis Woods (Random, 2002) are more compelling explorations of the intersection of young and old at differing stages of life's journey.—
Riva Pollard, The Winsor School Library, Boston Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--Ce texte provient de la
Hardcover
édition.