5.0 out of 5 stars
A Stunning Version of a Classic Tale, Dec 24 2007
I remember going to see "The Slipper and the Rose" at a local theatre in the summer of 1977 with my best friend, her mother, and her grandmother...and after the matinee credits rolled, we went into the lobby, phoned home to our scheduled "ride" and told them not to come back for another 2.5 hours, because we were going to stay and watch it again, it was so enchanting.
Later, when it was broadcast on a cable channel that my grad school roommate and I didn't get (being unable to afford cable on our meager budget), we splurged on a hotel room for the night to enjoy the show.
Say what you like about the uneven audio levels, the pacing, and so on...the flaws are more than made up for by excellent performances by some of the leading lights of British acting, by a lushly-costumed and lovingly-staged production, and most especially by the clever lyrics and tuneful melodies of the Sherman brothers. Anyone who can rhyme "Phineas" and "ignominious" is OK in my book, and numbers like "Why Can't I Be Two People?," "Secret Kingdom," "Protocoligorically Correct" and "What a Comforting Thing to Know" belong squarely alongside the best musical theatre numbers in the business. In fact, I would love to see "The Slipper and the Rose" revived as a stage production - the consciously-theatrical staging of many of the numbers already lends itself to it, and other Sherman outings like "Mary Poppins" and "Chitty Chitty Bang Bang" have already proven the concept.
If I have a criticism to raise as regards the DVD, it is that it offers only the "expanded" cut of the film, and not the original theatrical release version. In my view, the edits made for theatrical release were wise and lended needed pacing to the film. I'd have preferred to see the deleted numbers and scenes not edited back , but instead included as bonus material.
In any case, it's a film watchable again and again, and despite its being a product of its time, without the many bells and whistles now available, it's a splendid reinvisioning of a classic story, well worth including in anyone's film library.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Lovely film let down by a poor quality DVD, July 31 2006
The Slipper and the Rose is a musical version of Cinderella and stars Richard Chamberlain as the Prince who is being forced into choosing a bride but who yearns to find love. Gemma Craven is Cinderella, young and beautiful but forced into drudgery by her 'wicked stepmother' (Margaret Lockwood). Other well known faces are Kenneth More as the Lord Chamberlain, Michael Horden as the King, Annette Crosby as the fairy godmother and dame Edith Evans as the dowager queen.
The story closely follows the fairy story so beloved by generations of children but with the inclusion of numerous songs which, while not being works of musical genius, are very catchy nonetheless and find you tapping your foot alongside them. Although this film is almost 30 years old it should still entertain children (and young-at-heart adults) as much now as it did then.
The main flaw with this DVD, and the reason it lost a star, is its poor transfer from film. There has been no effort made to clean up the picture or sound, so it looks a little faded and grainy, and the sound is not nowhere as clear as it could be. In other words, if you already own this movie on VHS then the DVD really isn't worth purchasing but, if you don't already possess it, then it is worth buying purely for the entertainment value.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Not your mother's Cinderella, April 7 2004
I love this movie, absolutely and positively. Can't remember how I stumbled on it.
The DVD verious needs serious work by those who restore movies. The colors are awful and the editing of the last few minutes is unforgiveable.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No