2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A fresh take on the painful history of slavery in America, Feb 14 2012
By Civis - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Song of Slaves in the Desert (Paperback)
Novels about slavery in America must confront a painful history. What makes "Song of Slaves in the Desert" such an original and compelling read is that it confronts two painful histories at once--the slavery of Africans brought to labor in plantations in the antebellum South, and the slavery of Jews in the time of the Egyptian pharaohs.
Two people, Liza and Nathaniel, one a beautiful African slave girl and the other a young Jewish New Yorker, meet some years before the outbreak of the Civil War. When the book begins Nathaniel is carefree, a little naïve, a dreamer who longs to tour Europe. Before he can set sail for the continent his father sends him to Charleston to visit his uncle's rice plantation, so Nathaniel can learn about the business. At first Nathaniel is resentful about having to go to Charleston, and can't understand why he has to. But once he arrives in Charleston and meets Liza, who was born into slavery and works as a housemaid in his uncle's home, Nathaniel finds himself losing his heart to her. As he struggles to understand how his uncle, whose Jewish ancestors suffered enslavement in Egypt, can choose to become part of the slaveholding economy, Nathaniel faces a difficult decision: should he return to New York and try to forget Liza? Or betray his family trying to free her?
This novel makes big leaps in time and space: it begins in Timbuktu, Africa, and moves across vast geographies to tell the story of how Liza's ancestors came to be enslaved. The chapters alternate between Liza's family history and Nathaniel's story, occasionally interspersed with meditative chapters entitled "In My Margins," in which the narrator wrestles with the great subjects this book is concerned with: freedom, free will, love. Another reviewer here describes this book as "modern and inventive," and that sounds right to me. There's a wonderful chapter where Yemaya, an African goddess, bickers with Yahweh. It all unfolds naturally, as part of the action, the way Athena and Zeus quarrel in the Iliad.
"Song of Slaves in the Desert" is an epic ride through some of the darkest periods in human history. The story of Nathaniel and Liza is so engrossing, and the language so heart-rendingly gorgeous, I enjoyed every moment of the journey.
8 of 13 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Inventive, contemporary work deserves contemporary analysis, April 25 2011
By T. Donnelly - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Song of Slaves in the Desert: A Novel of Slavery and the Southern Wild (Hardcover)
On Cheuse's latest work I posted a similar comment to The Washington Post after reading a review. Now, I post a similar comment for contemporary readers and critics here:
Congratulations to Cheuse on creating an inventive, modern and epic novel and then having critics try to analyse it through the most conventional, archaic lenses. That is like trying to put a square peg in a round hole. Wonder why not one critic has yet to comment on the chapters, "In My Margins" which ask the reader and all of mankind through something akin to poetry to take a step back, weigh in, and look at what we have become and where we are going. I ask our contemporary critics and contemporary readers this: What do we want from a novel? What do we want from art?